![]() |
|
|
Vol. 295, Issue 1, 337-345, October 2000
,
21-Dihydroxy-3
-trifluoromethyl-19-nor-5
-pregnan-20-one), a
Selective Modulator of
-Aminobutyric AcidA Receptors
CoCensys, Inc., Irvine, California (K.E.V., J.E.H., N.C.L., P.L.W., R.B.C.); Wyeth-Ayerst Research, Neuroscience Research Division, Princeton, New Jersey (S.R.-L., J.E.B.); and Department of Pharmacology, College of Medicine, University of California Irvine, Irvine, California (J.D.B., L.S.)
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of a novel
neuroactive steroid, Co 2-6749 (GMA-839; WAY-141839; 3
, 21-dihydroxy-3
-trifluoromethyl-19-nor-5
-pregnan-20-one), on
-aminobutyric acidA receptors in vitro and to
define its anxiolytic-like effects and side effect profile in vivo. Co
2-6749 fully inhibited [35S]t-butylbicyclophosphorothionate
binding in rat brain cortical membranes with an IC50 value
of 230 nM and in human
-aminobutyric acidA receptor
subunit combinations of
1
2
2L,
2
2
2L,
3
2
2L,
4
3
2L,
5
2
2L, and
6
3
2L receptors
(IC50 values of 200, 200, 96, 2300, 210, and 2000 nM). Rats
were trained in a Geller-Seifter operant conflict paradigm. Co 2-6749 caused a dose-related increase in punished responding with a minimum
effective dose of 1.6 mg/kg, p.o., a wide therapeutic index relative to
a decrease in unpunished responding and relative to ataxia, and no
tolerance. Additionally, ethanol caused less than a 2-fold shift to the
left in the dose-response function of Co 2-6749 in the rotorod
procedure in rats. In a pigeon conflict paradigm, punished responding
was maximally increased to 784% of vehicle control by 30 mg/kg, p.o.,
with a 2-h duration and no effect on unpunished responding at this
dose. Similarly, punished responding in squirrel monkeys was maximally
increased to 1774% of control by 10 mg/kg, p.o., with no effect on
unpunished responding at this dose. With robust anxiolytic-like
activity across species, a large separation between anxiolytic-like
effects and sedation/ataxia, a minimal interaction with ethanol, a lack of tolerance, and apparent oral bioavailability, Co 2-6749 makes an
ideal candidate for development as a novel anxiolytic drug.
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cumulative
evidence supports the existence of discrete neuroactive steroid binding
sites on the
-aminobutyric acid (GABA)A receptor-Cl
ionophore complex (Gee et al.,
1995
; Lambert et al., 1995
). Endogenous metabolites of the steroid
hormone progesterone appear to interact with a unique recognition site
on the GABAA complex that is distinct from the
benzodiazepine and barbiturate binding sites (Gee et al., 1988
; Peters
et al., 1988
; Turner et al., 1989
), although specific binding by a
radiolabeled steroid has not yet been established. Electrophysiological
and 36Cl
uptake studies
demonstrate that neuroactive steroids exert positive modulatory effects
on GABA-evoked activity at nanomolar concentrations (Morrow et al.,
1987
; Purdy et al., 1990
; Woodward et al., 1992
). The kinetics of
inhibitory postsynaptic currents in single-channel recordings indicate
that such effects result from an increase in both the frequency and
duration of single GABAA receptor channel openings (Harrison et al., 1987
; Twyman and MacDonald, 1992
).
Consistent with their ability to facilitate GABAergic
neurotransmission, neuroactive steroids exhibit potent anxiolytic-like effects in a variety of animal models (Gasior et al., 1999
). By way of
example, the endogenous progesterone metabolites allopregnanolone (3
,5
-P; 3
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one) and pregnanolone
(3
,5
-P; 3
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one) produce anxiolytic-like
effects in such diverse rodent ethological procedures as light/dark
transition (Wieland et al., 1995
), elevated plus-maze (Bitran et al.,
1991
; Rodgers and Johnson, 1998
), defensive burying (Picazo and Fern ández-Guasti, 1995
), mirrored chamber (Reddy and Kulkarni, 1997
), and ultrasonic vocalization (Zimmerberg et al., 1994
; Vivian et al.,
1997
). In addition, neuroactive steroids demonstrate robust anxiolytic-like activity in conflict procedures. For example, endogenous neuroactive steroids increase punished drinking (Crawley et
al., 1986
; Carboni et al., 1996
; Vanover et al., 1999a
) and operant
punished responding (Wieland et al., 1995
; Brot et al., 1997
) in rats.
Similarly, the synthetic neuroactive steroids Co 3-0593 (Wieland et
al., 1997
) and alphaxolone (Britton et al., 1991
) were shown to
increase punished responding in rat operant conflict procedures.
The present experiments were conducted to characterize the in vitro
modulatory properties of a novel neuroactive steroid Co 2-6749 (GMA-839; WAY-141839; 3
,
21-dihydroxy-3
-trifluoromethyl-19-nor-5
-pregnan-20-one; Fig.
1) on recombinant human
GABAA receptors as well as to define its
anxiolytic-like effects in operant conflict paradigms in rats, pigeons,
and squirrel monkeys. In addition, the potential side effect profiles
of motor incoordination and interaction with ethanol were evaluated in
rats. Furthermore, the behavioral effects of Co 2-6749 were compared
with alprazolam in rats and with chlordiazepoxide in pigeons and
squirrel monkeys.
|
| |
Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
GABAA Receptor Binding
Stable GABAA Cell Line Preparation.
Human
1,
2,
3, and
2L GABAA receptor subunits
were a gift from Peter Seeburg (Max-Planck Institute for Medical
Research, Heidelberg, Germany). Human
4,
6, and
2 were
cloned as previously described (Yang et al., 1995
). Human
5 was
cloned from human brain by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using
oligonucleotide primers corresponding to the proposed ends of the
coding region based on the human
5 genomic sequence (Knoll et al.,
1993
). The amino acid sequence derived from this cDNA was identical
with the amino acid sequence subsequently reported (Wingrove et al., 1991
). Human
3 (Wafford et al., 1994
) was cloned from human brain by
PCR using oligonucleotide primers derived from the published sequences
corresponding to the ends of the coding region. All plasmid DNA for
transfection was prepared using two-cycle cesium-chloride-gradient centrifugation. The transfection of the HEK293 cells (CRL 1573; American Type Culture Collection, Manassas, VA) follows the protocol reported previously (Hawkinson et al., 1996
).
Membrane Preparation.
Membranes from stable HEK293 cell
lines expressing human recombinant GABAA receptor
subunit combinations and well washed rat brain cortical homogenates
were prepared as described previously (Hawkinson et al., 1996
).
[35S]t-Butylbicyclophosphorothionate
(TBPS) Assay.
Steroid inhibition of 2 nM
[35S]TBPS (60-100 Ci/mmol; NEN, Boston, MA)
binding was examined in 200 mM NaCl/50 mM sodium phosphate buffer (pH
7.4) as previously described (Hawkinson et al., 1996
). The GABA
concentrations were chosen to standardize conditions among cell lines
and were either the approximate IC50 for
inhibition of TBPS binding (rat brain) or the concentration producing
the peak TBPS binding from the biphasic GABA concentration-effect curve
(recombinant receptors) as indicated in Table
1. The incubation and filtration were
done as previously described (Hawkinson et al., 1996
) or in 96-well
plates (2.0 ml; Beckman, Fullerton, CA) followed by filtration
through GF/B 96-well filter plates (Packard, Meriden, CT), and rinsed
three times with ~1.5 ml of ice-cold assay buffer. In the latter
case, Microscint scintillation cocktail (50 µl; Packard) was added to
each well of the dried filter plates, and they were then sealed, shaken
vigorously for 5 min, and counted for 5 min/well on a TopCount
6-detector scintillation counter (Packard).
|
Data Analysis. Nonlinear curve fitting was done using Prism (GraphPad, San Diego, CA). The concentration of test compound producing 50% inhibition (IC50) of specific binding and the maximal extent of inhibition (Imax) were determined for the individual experiments and then the means ± S.E.M. were calculated.
Nontarget Receptor Binding Assays
The effects of Co 2-6749 on binding at cytosolic steroid receptors (PanLabs ProfilingScreen) and neurotransmitter receptors (NovaScreen) were also determined. The activity of Co 2-6749 was compared, for each assay, with that of a reference compound with known affinity. Each experiment was replicated three times.
Geller-Seifter
Animals and Apparatus. Male rats (Sprague-Dawley; Charles River Laboratories, Wilmington, MA; n = 6/group) weighing 250 to 300 g were housed individually in a room with a 12:12-h light/dark cycle. Rats were kept on a restricted diet of Purina Lab Chow (St. Louis, MO) to maintain stable body weights at 85% of their free-feeding young adult levels. Water was freely available in the home cage.
Experimental chambers consisted of standard operant chambers equipped with a lever mounted on one wall, a small dipper that delivered 0.1 ml of milk reinforcer, a stimulus light, a stimulus tone, and a stainless steel grid floor through which the foot shock punishment was administered (Coulbourn Instruments, Allentown, PA). Stimuli presentation and recording of lever presses were controlled by a DEC PDP 11/73 microcomputer running SKED (State Systems, Kalamazoo, MI) software.Procedure. During the daily 63-min sessions rats were allowed to press a lever to receive access to a sweetened milk solution. Initially, rats were allowed to respond on a continuous reinforcement schedule and progressed rapidly to 30-s, 1-min, and 2-min variable interval (VI) schedules of reinforcement. On the continuous reinforcement schedule, rats received access to a sweetened milk solution after every lever press. On the VI schedules, milk was available at variable intervals, eventually at an average of once every 2 min. Once responding was stable, four brief periods of punished responding (3 min) were introduced. The punished periods alternated with five periods of unpunished responding (the first unpunished component was 3 min, the others lasted 12 min). The unpunished component consisted of the milk reinforcer being available at infrequent and variable intervals (VI 2 min). The punished component consisted of each response resulting in a brief electric footshock (250-ms duration) in addition to the milk reinforcer and was signaled by a light and a tone. In untreated animals, the electric footshock was sufficient to decrease responding during the punished component. Shock intensity was 0.2 mA initially, and then increased daily in increments of 0.02 mA to gradually suppress lever pressing to five responses or fewer per punished component based on individual performance. An increase in punished responding compared with baseline behavior was interpreted as an anxiolytic-like effect. Unpunished responding was measured to evaluate nonspecific effects on behavior.
The dose-response function of each drug was determined. Each drug was administered orally before testing to separate groups of rats (n = 6 for each compound). Co 2-6749 was administered at doses of 1 to 32 mg/kg, p.o., 60 min before the session. Alprazolam was administered at doses of 8 to 64 mg/kg, p.o., 30 min before the session. In addition to the evaluation of the acute effects of Co 2-6749, possible development of tolerance was evaluated using daily administration of a peak anxiolytic-like dose (8 mg/kg, p.o.) for 2 weeks (n = 6).Data Analysis.
The number of lever presses during punished
and unpunished components was determined for each rat. Drug injections
were administered on Tuesdays and Fridays if baseline levels of
responding remained stable. Saline injections on Mondays and Thursdays
served as control. For test sessions, differences between vehicle
control and drug treatment were computed for punished (drug
vehicle) and unpunished (% control) lever presses for each rat. Thus,
each rat served as its own control. The data were then averaged across
rats and the standard error of the means were calculated. The minimum
effective dose (MED) was determined to be the dose at which punished
responses (drug
vehicle) were increased to a value of 20. The
minimum suppressive dose (MSD) was determined to be the dose at which unpunished responses (% control) decreased to 75%. Additionally, statistical comparisons were made on the individual difference scores
after each drug dose and its preceding vehicle baseline score, using
one-way ANOVA and individual post hoc comparisons with Bonferroni
correction for multiple comparisons. For the experiments of chronic
(14-day) dosing, values were averaged across rats and the standard
error of the means were calculated. The data are presented graphically.
Rotorod
Animals and Apparatus. Naive male rats (Sprague-Dawley; Harlan Sprague-Dawley, Inc., San Diego, CA; n = 8/group) weighing 200 to 225 g were housed (two per cage) in polycarbonate cages containing sterilized bedding material (Sani-Chips; P.J. Murray, Montville, NJ) in a room maintained at 23.0°C (± 2.5°C) and on a 12:12-h light/dark cycle. Food (Teklad LM 485; Harlan Teklad, Placentia, CA) and water were freely available in the home cage.
The rotorod test used a custom-built apparatus that consisted of an elevated drum (7.62-cm diameter) of textured surface that rotated at a constant speed (8 rpm). The height of the drum from the floor of the test apparatus was approximately 30 cm.Procedure. Before administration of test substance, rats were trained to walk continuously on the drum for a period of 90 s. During testing, rats were given three opportunities to remain on the apparatus continuously for 1 min. Remaining on the apparatus was scored as a pass. Results were treated quantally.
Doses ranged from 10 to 60 mg/kg for Co 2-6749 and from 5 to 40 mg/kg for alprazolam. Each dose was tested in a different group of rats. Time course was determined using a repeated testing protocol at 15 min, 30 min, 1 h, 1.5 h, 2 h, 3 h, and 4 h after administration. The dose-response function of Co 2-6749 (10-40 mg/kg, p.o.) was redetermined in the presence of a subataxic dose of ethanol (1 g/kg, administered i.p. 30 min before testing). Co 2-6749 was tested at the time of peak effect, 60 min after administration. Similarly, the dose-response function of alprazolam (1-20 mg/kg, p.o.) was redetermined at the time of peak effect (30 min) in the presence of ethanol (1 g/kg, administered i.p., 30 min).Data Analysis. Each dose-response function (n = 8-24/dose) was based on separate experiments (n = 8/dose) conducted on different days and the results summed. A dose that caused behavioral toxicity (i.e., falling from the rotorod apparatus) in half the animals (toxic dose; TD50) was calculated based on each dose response function using PHARM/PCS version 4.2 software (Springer Verlag, New York). In addition, the 95% confidence intervals were calculated around each TD50. A shift in the dose-response function in the presence of ethanol, such that the 95% confidence intervals of the two TD50 values did not overlap, was considered significant.
Pigeon Conflict
Animals and Apparatus. Seven white Carneaux male pigeons, approximately 1 year old, were obtained from the Palmetto Pigeon Plant (Sumter, SC). All pigeons were experimentally naïve and were maintained individually in cages provided with continuously available water and grit. Lighting in the temperature- and humidity-controlled vivarium was on a 12:12-h light/dark cycle. All pigeons were reduced to approximately 85% of their free-feeding body weights before key peck training and were maintained at this weight for the duration of the study.
Experimental sessions were conducted in a standard operant conditioning chamber placed inside a ventilated sound-attenuating shell that was equipped with white noise to mask extraneous sounds (Med Associates, Georgia, VT). The front panel of the chamber contained three response keys. The keys could be transilluminated with different colors. Only the center key was transilluminated and used in the present study. Pecks that exceeded approximately 0.15 N on the transilluminated center key operated a feedback relay behind the front wall and were counted as a response. Below the center key was a rectangular opening (4.5 × 10 cm) that provided access to a solenoid-driven food magazine containing mixed grain. During food delivery, the magazine was illuminated and the keylights were darkened. Electrodes were implanted with stainless steel electrodes wrapped around each pubis bone. The electrodes were connected with wire to a plug mounted on the back of an ultrasuede vest that was worn by the pigeon. Electric shock (1-3 mA, 200 ms) was delivered through a flexible cable attached from the ceiling of the chamber to the plug in the pigeon's vest. Impedance was checked daily to ensure proper functioning of the electrodes. Shock intensity was empirically determined to produce suppression of responding that was less than 10% of the unpunished response rate.Procedure. Pigeons were initially trained to key peck at the center white or red key. Initially, each response resulted in 3-s access to mixed grain. Gradually, the response requirement was raised to 30 (fixed ratio or FR30 schedule), such that every 30th response resulted in 3-s access to mixed grain. Once responding stabilized, shock was introduced during the red keylight stimulus. Shock intensity was varied in individual pigeons to establish a level that suppressed response rate to <10% of unpunished responding. In the presence of a white key, completion of an FR30 resulted in 3-s access to mixed grain. In the presence of the red key, completion of an FR30 resulted in 3-s access to mixed grain and a brief electric shock (1-3 mA, 200 ms). Experimental sessions consisted of 10 (five of each) alternating 3-min components of the unpunished (white key) and punished (red key) schedule conditions. The alternating components were separated by a 30-s timeout period during which all illumination in the chamber was extinguished.
Data Analysis. Rates of responding (responses/s) were calculated for unpunished and punished components. Mean control rates for both unpunished and punished responding were determined by averaging data from all noninjection and vehicle control sessions that preceded drug test sessions. The effects of each dose were calculated as a percentage of the mean control rates for individual subjects. Drug effects were considered significant in an individual animal when the rate of responding differed by more than 2 standard deviations from the mean control rate of responding. Group means and S.E.M. are presented graphically.
Squirrel Monkey Conflict
Animals and Apparatus. Three adult male squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus) weighing 0.87 to 0.95 kg lived in individual home cages except during experimental sessions. Squirrel monkeys were maintained at 85% of their free-feeding body weights by regulating their daily portion of Purina Monkey Chow. Monkeys were supplemented with fresh fruits and vegetables and had unlimited access to water in their home cages.
Experimental sessions were conducted in ventilated sound-attenuating chambers that were provided with white noise to mask extraneous sounds. Monkeys sat in a Plexiglas chair similar to the one used by Morse and Kelleher (1966)Procedure. Monkeys were initially trained to lever press on the right lever in the presence of white or red stimulus lights. Initially, each response (FR1) resulted in a food pellet reinforcer. Gradually, the response requirement was increased to 30 (FR30) such that every 30th response resulted in a food pellet reinforcer. Once responding stabilized, shock was introduced on an FR50 schedule when the red stimulus lights were illuminated. Under this schedule (FR30, food; FR50, shock), completion of 30 responses resulted in a food pellet reinforcer and completion of 50 responses resulted in a mild electric shock. Shock intensity was varied in individual monkeys to establish a level that suppressed response rate to <10% of unpunished responding. Experimental sessions consisted of four response components each preceded by a 10-min timeout period. Each response component consisted of a 3-min period of unpunished responding (white stimulus lights) followed by a short timeout (30 s) followed by a 3-min period of punished responding (red stimulus lights).
Data Analysis. Rates of responding (responses/s) were calculated for each of the unpunished and punished response periods. Mean control rates for both unpunished and punished responding were determined by averaging data from all noninjection and vehicle control sessions that preceded drug test sessions. The effects of each dose were calculated as a percentage of the mean control rates for individual subjects. For both compounds, only response rates in the first component were included in the analysis because maximal drug effects were observed for both drugs in this component. Drug effects were considered significant in any individual animal when the rate of responding differed by more than 2 standard deviations from the mean control rate of responding. Group means and S.E.M. are presented graphically.
Drugs
Co 2-6749 (CoCensys, Inc., Irvine, CA) was dissolved in a
vehicle of 50:50 (w/v) hydroxypropyl-
-cyclodextrin (HP
CD):0.9% saline (designated as 50% HP
CD) and sonicated overnight for the experiments in rats. Co 2-6749 was diluted with saline to a final concentration of 10% HP
CD. Co 2-6749 was dissolved in polyethylene glycol (PEG) 200 for the pigeon and squirrel monkey experiments. Alprazolam (Research Biochemicals International, Natick, MA; Sigma, St.
Louis, MO; Wyeth-Ayerst, Princeton, NJ) was dissolved in a vehicle of
90% PEG 400:10% Tween 80 for the experiments in rats. Chlordiazepoxide (Wyeth-Ayerst) was dissolved in either 0.9% NaCl or
sterile H2O for the pigeon and squirrel monkey
experiments. Co 2-6749 and/or alprazolam were administered orally in a
volume of 5 ml/kg in rats, and 1 to 2 ml/kg in pigeons and monkeys.
Chlordiazepoxide was administered i.m. in a volume of 1 ml/kg in
pigeons and <0.4 total ml volume in monkeys.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
GABAA Receptor Binding.
Co 2-6749 had moderate
potency for inhibition of [35S]TBPS binding in
rat brain cortical membranes with an IC50 value
of 230 ± 20 nM (Fig. 2; Table 1).
Co 2-6749 fully inhibited the binding of
[35S]TBPS with an
Imax value of 97 ± 2%. The slope of
the inhibition curve was close to unity (1.16). Co 2-6749 was 4.5-fold
less potent than 3
,5
-P in this assay.
|
3
2
2L receptors
(IC50 value of 96 nM) (Table 1; Fig. 2). Co
2-6749 was ~2-fold less potent at
1
2
2L,
2
2
2L, and
5
2
2L receptors (IC50 values of ~200
nM), and ~20-fold less potent at
4
3
2L and
6
3
2L
receptors. 3
,5
-P exhibited a similar profile, but was 5- to
11-fold more potent than Co 2-6749 at
1
2
2L,
2
2
2L,
3
2
2L, and
5
2
2L receptors (Hawkinson et al., 1996
,5
-P was <2-fold more potent than Co 2-6749 at
4
3
2L and
6
3
2L receptors.
Nontarget Receptor Binding.
Co 2-6749 exhibited negligible
inhibition (IC50 >10 µM) in radioligand
binding assays for a large number of nontarget receptors, including
cytosolic steroid, inhibitory amino acid, excitatory amino acid,
monoamine, and peptide receptors (Table
2).
|
Geller-Seifter. Vehicle control values of unpunished responding ranged from 379 to 5704 responses and punished responding ranged from 0 to 24 responses, but values were more stable within any given animal (generally ±20%). Note 24 responses after vehicle administration occurred one time in one rat; responding after vehicle administration was usually fewer than 20 responses, the criteria for a minimum effective dose.
Co 2-6749 (1-16 mg/kg, p.o., 60 min) caused a dose-related increase in punished responding up to 8 mg/kg (Fig. 3). The doses of 4 and 8 mg/kg were statistically greater than vehicle control (P = .0041 and P = .0089, respectively). Co 2-6749 decreased unpunished responding at 16 mg/kg, but the effect was not statistically different from control (P = .2162). The MED of Co 2-6749 was 1.6 mg/kg and the MSD was 13.2 mg/kg (Table 3). The mean maximum effect for Co 2-6749 was 78.8 punished responses and occurred at 8 mg/kg.
|
|
|
Rotorod.
Co 2-6749 (10-40 mg/kg, p.o., 60 min) caused a
dose-related increase in the number of rats failing the rotorod assay
(i.e., falling off the apparatus; Fig.
5). Loss of righting reflex was observed
at higher doses (data not shown). The peak effect, including the number
exhibiting loss of righting reflex, appeared to be 60 min after
administration. The duration of action was dose-related with higher
doses lasting longer. The TD50 of Co 2-6749 was
25.3 mg/kg (95% confidence interval: 19.5-32.8) administered alone at
the time of peak effect and was 15.5 mg/kg (12.5-19.2) in combination with a subataxic dose (1.0 g/kg, i.p., 30 min) of ethanol (Fig. 5;
Table 3).
|
Pigeon Conflict. Administration of saline or sterile H2O engendered rates of responding of 2.84 ± 0.26 responses/s (mean ± S.E.M.) and 0.07 ± 0.05 responses/s in unpunished and punished components, respectively. Compared with control sessions, unpunished responding was 101% of control and punished responding was 80% of control. Administration of PEG 200 (2× volume, p.o.) engendered rates of responding of 3.20 ± 0.12 and 0.27 ± 0.12 responses/s in unpunished and punished components, respectively. Compared with control sessions, unpunished responding was 116% of control and punished responding was 611% of control. The apparent increase in punished responding was reflected by increases in punished responding in three of seven pigeons.
Co 2-6749 (3-56 mg/kg, p.o., 30 min) produced dose-dependent increases in punished responding at doses below those that affected unpunished responding (Fig. 6). Punished responding was maximally increased by 30 mg/kg, with rates of responding increased to 5714% of control values (784% of PEG 200 control). At this dose (30 mg/kg), unpunished rates of responding were not changed, with rates of 103% of control values (86% of PEG 200 control). A higher dose of Co 2-6749 (56 mg/kg) also produced large increases in punished responding (4321% of control values; 450% of PEG 200 control). Unpunished rates of responding were reduced to 71% of control (59% of PEG 200 control).
|
Squirrel Monkey Conflict. Administration of saline engendered rates of responding of 2.30 ± 0.15 responses/s (mean ± S.E.M.) and 0.06 ± 0.06 responses/s in unpunished and punished components, respectively. Compared with control sessions, unpunished responding was 96% of control and punished responding was 74% of control. Administration of PEG 400/Tween (2× volume, p.o.) engendered rates of responding of 2.83 ± 0.32 and 0.12 ± 0.12 responses/s in unpunished and punished components, respectively. Compared with control sessions, unpunished responding was 118% of control and punished responding was 85% of control.
Co 2-6749 (0.3-56 mg/kg, p.o., 30 min) produced dose-dependent increases in punished responding at doses below those that affected unpunished responding (Fig. 7). Punished responding was maximally increased by 10 mg/kg, with rates of responding increased to 1774% of control values. At this dose (10 mg/kg), unpunished rates of responding were not changed, with rates of 88% of control values. The large error bars at 1 and 3 mg/kg reflect that only one of three monkeys showed an increase in punished responding at these doses. At the higher doses (10-30 mg/kg) there were large increases in punished responding for all three monkeys. Only one monkey was studied at 56 mg/kg and this dose completely eliminated responding.
|
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The present study shows that Co 2-6749 is a selective steroid
modulator of the GABAA receptor complex in vitro.
Co 2-6749 was generally less potent than allopregnanolone at inhibiting [35S]TBPS binding to native and recombinant
human receptor combinations. Whereas the effects of benzodiazepines at
GABAA receptor isoforms are clearly influenced by
subunit composition, neuroactive steroids do not require a strict
subunit composition for activity (Lambert et al., 1995
). In the present
study, the
-subtype (
1,
2,
3,
5) had little or no
influence on the interaction, although Co 2-6749 displayed low potency
at
4/6
3
2L receptor complexes. The latter result may indicate
that Co 2-6749 displays selectivity for
1,
2,
3, and
5-containing complexes or alternatively that it has low activity at
3 relative to
2-containing complexes. Unfortunately, direct
comparisons could not be made because membranes from
4
2
2L-expressing cells did not bind
[35S]TBPS and cells expressing
6b2
2L were
not viable.
Co 2-6749 produced dose-dependent increases in punished responding in
rats, pigeons, and monkeys, consistent with anxiolytic-like effects in
multiple species. Although anxiolytic-like pharmacology is similar
across species, not all clinically useful anxiolytics are robust in all
three species; buspirone is a noted exception as reviewed by Pollard
and Howard (1990)
. That the current data are orderly and consistent
across species argues for a strong predictive validity to humans.
In rats maintained under the Geller-Seifter procedure, Co 2-6749 exhibited a minimum effective dose of 1.6 mg/kg, p.o. Co 2-6749 was more potent than the prototypical anxiolytic drug alprazolam, which exhibited a minimum effective dose of 8.1 mg/kg, p.o. Co 2-6749 increased punished responding in pigeons and squirrel monkeys at doses that did not affect unpunished responding, an effect and potency similar to that observed with chlordiazepoxide. More importantly, Co 2-6749 increased punished responding in all species tested with an effect size comparable to that of the benzodiazepines. In the Geller-Seifter procedure, the maximum mean number of punished responses was 78.8 for Co 2-6749 and occurred at a dose of 8 mg/kg. Although it is possible that a higher dose of alprazolam might show a further increase of punished responses in rats, the maximum mean number of punished responses of the doses tested was 83.7 and occurred at the highest dose tested (64 mg/kg). Alprazolam engendered a robust increase in unpunished behavior in rats, as well, whereas Co 2-6749 had a lesser effect on unpunished behavior relative to alprazolam. Neither Co 2-6749 nor chlordiazepoxide exhibited an increase of unpunished responding in pigeons or squirrel monkeys.
Activity of Co 2-6749 after repeated administration also was evaluated.
Co 2-6749 continued to produce a robust increase in punished responding
after daily dosing for 14 consecutive days. Although further evaluation
using different doses and dosing intervals would be useful, the present
lack of tolerance contrasts with tolerance to anxiolytic-like and
sedative effects after daily dosing of benzodiazepine receptor ligands
of both short and long duration (Soderpalm et al., 1989
).
Interestingly, unpunished responding gradually increased with repeated
administration of Co 2-6749. This drift upwards in unpunished
responding with repeated administration has been previously observed in
multiple species and with neuroactive steroids, benzodiazepines, and
barbiturates (Margules and Stein, 1968
; Cook and Sepinwall, 1975
;
Witkin and Barrett, 1981
; Wieland et al., 1997
). The phenomenon has
been attributed to "disinhibition" of a generalized suppression of
baseline unpunished responding by the punished component (Margules and
Stein, 1968
). The interaction between the components of a multiple
schedule after the introduction of punishment into one component is
known (behavioral contrast), although the direction of the change is
generally the opposite of that postulated in the aforementioned case
(Brethower and Reynolds, 1962
; Terrace, 1968
; Cook and Sepinwall,
1975
). The variables determining a result of behavioral contrast
compared with a result of a change of the behavior in the same
direction remain unclear.
In rats, Co 2-6749 exhibited a large therapeutic index (TI) between its minimum effective dose and its behavioral suppressive dose (Geller-Seifter TI = 8.3). In addition, Co 2-6749 showed a large separation between its minimum effective dose and its ataxic dose (rotorod TI = 15.8). This compares favorably to alprazolam that only showed a 3-fold separation between its minimum effective dose in Geller-Seifer and its ataxic dose in the rotorod procedure. It is curious that alprazolam was apparently more potent in producing ataxia in the rotorod procedure (TD50 = 26.8 mg/kg, p.o.) than it was in suppressing unpunished responding in the Geller-Seifter procedure (minimum suppressive dose >64 mg/kg, p.o.). This apparent discrepancy may be due to the fact that the rotorod is a brief test of less than 2-min duration, whereas the Geller-Seifter procedure samples behavior over a period of an hour. It is probable that the ataxic effects of alprazolam are short in duration and diminish during the course of the Geller-Seifter session. Alternatively, the rotorod procedure, which used naïve animals, may be more sensitive to the effects of alprazolam than the Geller-Seifter procedure, which used animals with a history of drug administration.
In addition to its robust anxiolytic-like activity and its minimal
sedative/ataxic effects, Co 2-6749 shows another distinct advantage
over existing benzodiazepines. Benzodiazepines demonstrate interactions
with ethanol that result in increased sedation and motor
incapacitation. Previous studies suggest that neuroactive steroids
exhibit a lesser propensity for adverse interaction with ethanol than
do benzodiazepines (Edgar et al., 1997
; Vanover et al., 1999b
). The
present studies demonstrate that Co 2-6749 shows minimal interaction
with ethanol insomuch as the ataxic effects of high doses of Co 2-6749 are shifted less than 2-fold to the left in the presence of a subataxic
does of ethanol. In contrast, there was greater than a 2-fold leftward
shift in the ataxic effects of alprazolam. Although the differences
between the effects of ethanol on Co 2-6749 and alprazolam ataxia are
small, it is important to note that even in the presence of ethanol,
there is an approximate 10-fold separation between the anxiolytic and
ataxic dose of Co 2-6749. This is in contrast to alprazolam, which has
a separation of less than 2-fold.
With robust anxiolytic-like activity, a large separation between
anxiolytic-like effects and sedation/ataxia, and apparent oral
bioavailability, Co 2-6749 makes an ideal candidate for development as
a novel anxiolytic drug. In addition, the lack of tolerance in the
Geller-Seifter procedure after 14-day dosing demonstrates the potential
of this compound as an effective treatment for chronic anxiety
disorders. Furthermore, recent results suggest that neuroactive steroids show less abuse potential than do benzodiazepines (Rowlett et
al., 1999
). Decreased abuse liability together with the lack of
interaction with ethanol would present a potential advantage over
currently available benzodiazepine anxiolytics.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank Dr. H. Xia for organic synthesis; M. Acosta-Burruel for radioligand binding; and S. Abrol, R. Brandsgaard, M. Finn, S. Robledo, M. Suruki, and P. T. Tran for animal studies.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Accepted for publication June 26, 2000.
Received for publication March 23, 2000.
1 Present address: ACADIA Pharmaceuticals, 3911 Sorrento Valley Blvd., San Diego, CA 92121-1402.
2 Present address: Elan Pharmaceuticals, 3760 Haven Ave., Menlo Park, CA 94025-1012.
3 Present address: Centaur Pharmaceuticals, 484 Oakmead Pkwy., Sunnyvale, CA 94086.
Send reprint requests to: Kimberly E. Vanover, Ph.D., In Vivo Pharmacology, ACADIA Pharmaceuticals, 3911 Sorrento Valley Blvd., San Diego, CA 92121-1402. E-mail: kvanover{at}acadia-pharm.com
| |
Abbreviations |
|---|
GABA,
-aminobutyric acid;
3
,5
-P, allopregnanolone, 3
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one;
3
,5
-P, pregnanolone, 3
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one;
Co 2-6749, 3
,
21-dihydroxy-3
-trifluoromethyl-19-nor-5
-pregnan-20-one (GMA-839;
WAY-141839), PCR, polymerase chain reaction;
TBPS, t-butylbicyclophosphorothionate;
VI, variable interval;
MED, minimum effective dose;
MSD, minimum suppressive dose;
FR, fixed ratio;
HP
CD, hydroxypropyl-
-cyclodextrin;
PEG, polyethylene glycol;
TD50, toxic dose50;
TI, therapeutic index.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-hydroxy-5
[
]-pregnan-20-one: Endogenous metabolites of progesterone that are active at the GABAA receptor.
Brain Res
561:
157-161[Medline].
-Hydroxy-3
-trifluoromethyl-5
-pregnan-20-one (Co 2-1970): A partial agonist at the neuroactive steroid site of the
-aminobutyric acidA receptor.
Mol Pharmacol
49:
897-906[Abstract].
-aminobutyric acid receptor complex at a site distinct from barbiturates.
J Pharmacol Exp Ther
248:
960-966
-aminobutyric acidA receptor complex and the neurosteroid recognistion site.
J Pharmacol Exp Ther
282:
318-325
subunit.
Neuron
12:
775-782[Medline].
-OH,5
-pregnan-20-one and 3
-OH,5
-pregnan-20-one in rodents.
Psychopharmacology
118:
65-71[Medline].
5 subunit.
Biochem Soc Trans
20:
S18.
-aminobutyric acid receptors expressed in Xenopus oocytes by poly (A)+ RNA from mammalian brain and retina.
J Pharmacol Exp Ther
41:
89-103.
4 subunit: Identification of a unique diazepam-insensitive binding site.
Eur J Pharmacol Mol Pharmacol
291:
319-325[Medline].
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||