Agricultural and Environmental Chemistry Group and Department of
Environmental Science, Policy, and Management, University of
California, Berkeley, California
Primary aliphatic alcohols from hexanol to pentadecanol were tested for
their effects on the succinate-supported respiration of intact
mitochondria isolated from rat liver. Alkanols were found to inhibit
State 3 and uncoupled respiration. The ADP/oxygen ratios, a measure of
the efficiency of oxidative phosphorylation, also were lowered, but to
a lesser degree when compared on the basis of percentage of controls.
Given each alkanol's nearly identical effect on State 3 and uncoupled
respiration, action is not directly on ATP synthase, but earlier in the
respiratory process. In agreement with many other studies of the
homologous series of alkanols, potency increased with number of carbons
in the chain until reaching a peak, in this case at undecanol, then
tapered off to tridecanol before reaching a cutoff, at tetradecanol. If
tetradecanol or longer homologs have activity, it is only after a lag
phase of >15-min preincubation. All alkanols up to tridecanol also
acted as uncouplers. At higher doses, hexanol inhibited State 4 rates, whereas longer chain alkanols did not, even at doses that completely eliminated respiratory control. Hexanol and decanol also were assayed
against freeze-thawed (broken) mitochondria to distinguish effects on
the mitochondrial substrate carrier from those on the electron
transport chain. Both compounds were only weak inhibitors of
respiration in broken mitochondria, suggesting that inhibition originates from interference with the dicarboxylate carrier, which must
transport succinate across the mitochondrial membranes before it can be
fed into complex II, rather than affecting the electron transport chain itself.
 |
Introduction |
Aliphatic
alcohols are among the most widespread compounds found to occur
naturally in plants and foods. At higher concentrations, they are known
to cause a variety of biochemical responses. The fact that aliphatic
alcohols are relatively stable and nonreactive has led to their use as
models for the study of drug-target mechanisms, especially for modeling
amphiphilic, head-tail type compounds. They have repeatedly been used
in studies of the mechanisms of anesthesia (Pringle et al., 1981
;
Franks and Lieb, 1986
; Alifimoff et al., 1989
; Miller et al., 1989
;
Chiou et al., 1990
) because they fit the trends described by the
Meyer-Overton rule, which correlates anesthetic potency with lipid
solubility (Meyer and Hemmi, 1935
). At concentrations higher than those
needed to induce anesthesia, alkanols can cause death and we reported
their potential for use as a means of pest control against larval
mosquitoes (Hammond and Kubo, 1999
). In mosquitoes, potency increased
with chain length until leveling off at undecanol and eventually
reaching a cutoff after pentadecanol, with the activity of tetradecanol
and pentadecanol occurring only after a lag-phase of several hours. The
variety of biological functions affected by alkanols leaves some doubt, however, as to the actual mechanisms responsible for death, and whether
these mechanisms overlap at all with those of general anesthesia. In
this article, we have examined the effects of alkanols on respiration
of intact mitochondria to see whether their activity occurs at relevant
concentrations, whether it follows the same trends regarding lipid
solubility as those observed in vivo, and whether they have the same
characteristics of cutoff seen in other test systems. Butanol,
pentanol, and hexanol were previously reported to inhibit localized
enzymes of the electron transport chain, albeit at relatively high
concentrations for most sites (Chazotte and Vanderkooi, 1981
). A
kinetic study examined alkanol inhibition of cytochrome c
oxidase alone, finding activity up to tetradecanol, but not for
hexadecanol (Hasinoff and Davey, 1989
). An analysis of the uncoupling
properties of n-hexane, hexanol, and 1-hexanethiol resulted
in the conclusion that they uncouple mitochondrial respiration by a
nonprotonophoric mechanism (Canton et al., 1996
). Measurement of
alkanols' effects on intact mitochondria is an essential intermediate step to linking their action in enzyme assays to their action in living
organisms. Our review of the literature indicates that this is the
first study to measure the effects of medium- or long-chain alcohols
and herein establish the point of cutoff in intact mitochondria. It is
also the first attempt to measure the effects of alkanols on a
mitochondrial substrate carrier.
 |
Experimental Procedures |
Animals.
Male Sprague-Dawley mice were purchased at 2 to 3 months of age (200-300 g) from Simonsen Laboratories (Gilroy, CA) and
fed on a normal diet. They were fasted for approximately 14 h
before removal of the liver.
Materials.
Alkanols were purchased from Aldrich (Milwaukee,
WI), were the highest grade available, were checked for purity by
thin-layer chromatography, and were used without further purification:
octanol, >99%; decanol, undecanol, and pentadecanol, 99%; hexanol
and dodecanol, 98%; and tridecanol and tetradecanol, 97%. Substrates,
inhibitors, and buffer constituents were all obtained from Sigma
Chemical Co. (St. Louis, MO). Cytochrome c from horse heart
(Sigma catalog no. C2506) was 95% pure and the solution was prepared
fresh for each day's experiments.
Isolation of Mitochondria.
Liver mitochondria were isolated
from fasted rats by the established methods. The rat was briefly
anesthetized with isoflurane ("iso-thesia"; Abbott Laboratories,
North Chicago, IL) and then exsanguinated by laceration of the jugular
vein. The liver was quickly excised and placed in ice-cold
homogenization buffer (210 mM mannitol, 70 mM sucrose, 5 mM HEPES, and
1 mM EDTA, and adjusted to pH 7.4). All subsequent isolation work was
performed at 0-4°C. The liver was minced with surgical scissors and
homogenized with a Potter-Elvehjem tissue grinder and Teflon pestle
(Kontes, Vineland, NJ) connected to a Heidolph RZR-1 stirrer
(Pennsauken, NJ) operated at a duty cycle of 3.5, approximately 600 rpm. This homogenate was centrifuged for 10 min at approximately
700g; the supernatant was poured off to another tube, the
pellet was resuspended, and both were centrifuged a second time under
the same conditions to precipitate nuclear and cellular debris. The
mitochondria in the resulting supernatant were isolated by
centrifugation for 10 min at approximately 8000g. The
supernatant was poured off, the pellet was gently resuspended in 40 ml
of buffer, and centrifuged one more time for 10 min at
8000g. The mitochondrial pellet was gently loosened,
removed, and stored on ice without dilution (typical yield
approximately 1.2 ml) for experiments the same day. Mitochondrial protein concentration was determined by the biuret method with BSA as standard.
Intact mitochondria were used immediately on isolation. Broken
mitochondria were prepared by subjecting the preparation to two
freeze-thaw cycles at
20°C and 2°C, respectively. Data for comparison of intact and broken mitochondria were collected with mitochondrial preparations independent from the preparations used to
measure respiratory control and ADP/oxygen ratios.
Polarographic Measurements of Oxygen Consumption.
Oxygen
consumption measurements were performed with a Clark style electrode
and an oxygraph equipped with a water-jacketed chamber maintained at
20°C (all from Yellow Springs Instrument Co., Yellow Springs, OH).
The assay buffer solution consisted of 154 mM KCl, 1 mM EGTA, 5 mM
K2HPO4, and 3 mM
MgCl2, adjusted to pH 7.4. Alkanols were added to
the buffer from a dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) solution; sonication was
used to facilitate solubilization of high concentrations and longer
chain alcohols. Mitochondria (1 mg of mitochondrial protein/ml of assay
buffer) were preincubated with continuous stirring for 15 min, when
rotenone (1 µM) was added to block respiration through complex I and
the reaction was started by addition of succinate (5 mM) as substrate.
The total assay volume was 3 ml. Controls were treated with the highest dose of DMSO used in each set of experiments, which never exceeded 0.4% and had no discernible effect on respiration. After a slow rate
of respiration had stabilized in the initial resting state (State 2),
State 3 respiration was initiated by addition of 200 µM ADP. When all
ADP has been consumed, respiration returns to a resting rate (State 4).
Functional integrity of the mitochondria was measured in terms of
respiratory control ratio (RCR), defined as the ratio of the rate of
State 3/State 4. RCR values averaged 4.5. Uncoupled respiration was
measured after addition of the classic uncoupler of oxidative
phosphorylation, carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone
(CCCP; 0.15 µM).
Oxygen Consumption by Freeze-Thawed Mitochondria.
Experiments concerning the effect of alkanols on intact versus
freeze-thawed mitochondria were performed in the manner described above
for intact, coupled mitochondria with the exception of a few
modifications. The preincubation period was 5 to 10 min, with preincubation and all respiration measurements performed at 30°C. Respiration was measured with 0.2 mg of mitochondrial protein/ml of
assay buffer except where noted.
Because breaking the mitochondrial membranes allows endogenous
cytochrome c, which freely floats along the intermembrane
surface of the inner membrane rather than being membrane-bound, to be
washed away, the assay buffer for experiments with freeze-thawed
mitochondria included a final concentration of 60 µM cytochrome
c added as 10 µl of an aqueous solution. Freeze-thawed mitochondria are inherently uncoupled by the act of breaking the membranes and only the uncoupled state of respiration was measured; this rate was compared with uncoupled respiration in intact
mitochondria effected by addition of the least amount of CCCP that
would maximally stimulate respiration rates without causing any
subsequent inhibition (0.1-0.15 µM). The functional integrity of
intact mitochondria was verified before uncoupling by at least two
assays yielding an RCR of at least 4.5.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 1
Alkanol concentrations (micromolar ± S.E.) causing 50%
inhibition (IC50) in the rate of State 3 respiration, uncoupled
respiration, and in the RCR of intact mitochondria isolated from rat
liver
Data for State 4 respiration refers to the concentration causing 50%
stimulation (EC50), and gaps in this column signify that 50%
stimulation was not reached (tetradecanol and pentadecanol) or the RCR
was decreased to approximately 1 before State 4 reached 50%
stimulation (undecanol). Data for mosquito refers to the in vivo
LD50 for first instars of C. tarsalis (Hammond and
Kubo, 1999 ).
|
|
Hexanol and decanol were chosen as key representative compounds to
model the general effects of alkanols on intact versus freeze-thawed
mitochondria because the former is considered a medium-chain alcohol
and the latter a long-chain alcohol. Longer chain lengths were rejected
as candidates for this study due to the additional confusion posed by
their relative insolubility in aqueous media at the concentrations
yielding high levels of activity.
Average respiration rates were taken from a minimum of five separate
experiments for each compound-concentration pair and the standard error
for these measurements. Each experiment was compared with its
respective control respiration rate, which was measured the same day
with the same mitochondrial preparation (between 4 and 10 controls
measured each day) and assigned a baseline value of 100%.
Data Analysis for Intact Mitochondria.
To calibrate for the
gradual respiration changes that occur within hours of isolating intact
mitochondria, control assays were conducted throughout each day's
experiments. The respiration rates of these controls (minimum of five)
were plotted and used as the benchmark for comparison with alkanol
treatments conducted that day. Each compound-concentration pair was
tested at least in triplicate. The IC50 and
EC50 values presented in Table
1 were derived by fitting a nonlinear
regression curve (SigmaPlot 4.0) to the inhibition data and solving for
y = 50. The best curve fit was obtained with the cubic
polynomial equation y = y0 + ax + bx2 + cx3.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 2
Respiratory inhibition (percentage of control) as a function of
mitochondrial protein concentration
Each number is the average of at least five replicates (0.2 mg of
protein) or three replicates (0.1 mg of protein).
|
|
Oxygen consumption values presented in Figs.
1 to 3 were calculated by assuming a
total of 510 nmol of molecular oxygen/ml of assay buffer at 20°C. The
data presented in this study derives from experiments on mitochondria
from approximately 20 animals and more than 100 control experiments.

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1.
Change in State 3 respiration after treatment with
various alkanols. Alkanols inhibit State 3 respiration in a
dose-dependent manner. Potency peaks at undecanol, then tapers off
until a cutoff, such that pentadecanol was completely inactive. Average
control value was approximately 72 nmol of oxygen/min/mg of protein.
|
|
 |
Results |
Primary aliphatic alcohols of 6, 8, and 10 to 15 carbons were
assayed against succinate-supported mitochondrial respiration up to the
concentration of each alkanol that completely abolished respiratory
control (RCR
1.1) from that preparation's average control value.
There were multiple effects, simultaneously influencing all respiration
states measured, as outlined below. Undecanol was the most potent
compound in each category (Table 1).
Effects of Alkanols on State 3 Respiration.
Alkanols inhibited
succinate-supported State 3 respiration in a dose-dependent manner.
Potency increased with increasing chain length up to undecanol, then
tapered off such that dodecanol was similar in potency to decanol, and
potency of tridecanol was between that of octanol and decanol (Table
1). Tetradecanol appeared to have some inhibitory effect on State
3, but the data obtained was not consistently linear or dose dependent
(see Discussion for possible explanation). Pentadecanol
caused no measurable inhibition up to the maximum dose tested, which is
well beyond its solubility limit (Fig. 1).
Effects of Alkanols on State 4 Respiration.
All compounds up
to 13 carbons caused uncoupling (stimulation) of State 4 respiration at
low doses, potency increasing with chain length. However, the effects
of higher doses (i.e., concentrations greater than needed to abolish
respiratory control) were not the same throughout the alkanol series.
Hexanol stimulated State 4 respiration at low concentrations and
inhibited it at higher concentrations, whereas for longer alkanols,
State 4 respiration was stimulated only; progressively higher doses of
longer chain homologs exerted no inhibitory effect on State 4 respiration (Fig. 2). No effect of
tetradecanol or pentadecanol on State 4 respiration was detected.

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
Change in State 4 respiration after treatment with
various alkanols. Octanol and longer chain alkanols act as uncouplers.
Hexanol uncouples at low concentrations and inhibits State 4 respiration at higher concentrations. Average control value was
approximately 16 nmol of oxygen/min/mg of protein.
|
|
Effects of Alkanols on Uncoupled Respiration.
Respiration
uncoupled by CCCP, which normally results in a rate comparable with
that of State 3 respiration, was inhibited by alkanols in a
dose-response fashion similar to that of State 3 (Fig.
3). Inhibitory potency increased with
chain length, peaked at undecanol, then tapered off to tridecanol.
Neither tetradecanol nor pentadecanol exhibited any effect on
respiration uncoupled by CCCP. However, just as for State 4 respiration, hexanol affected uncoupled respiration differently than
long-chain alcohols. When applied at concentrations that lowered RCR to
approximately 1, hexanol inhibited uncoupled respiration by >80%,
whereas octanol, decanol, undecanol, dodecanol, and tridecanol lowered
uncoupled rates of respiration by approximately 67, 70, 67, 68, and
55%, respectively. Whereas several experiments with high
concentrations of hexanol produced a rate of uncoupled respiration even
lower than the State 4 rate of controls, the longer chain alkanols
reduced uncoupled respiration only to a rate similar to that of State 4, but no lower (Fig. 4), even when the
dose was increased severalfold.

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
Effect of various alkanols on the rate of uncoupled
respiration. Almost identical with State 3, uncoupled respiration is
inhibited in a dose-dependent manner, with potency peaking at undecanol
and pentadecanol completely inactive. Average control value was
approximately 81 nmol of oxygen/min/mg of protein.
|
|

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Effects of decanol (top) and hexanol (bottom) on
succinate-supported mitochondrial respiration. Each trace depicts a
representative experiment, in which the reaction was started by adding
succinate (leftmost arrow of each trace), State 3 was initiated with
ADP (second arrow of each trace), and uncoupled respiration with CCCP
(third arrow). Assay conditions and concentrations are given in
Experimental Procedures. Note that in the highest
concentration experiments, where respiratory control had already been
abolished, additional doses of hexanol (5 mM each arrow) decreased the
rate of uncoupled respiration below the State 4 rate, whereas higher
doses of decanol (400 µM each arrow) did not.
|
|
Effects of Alkanols on ADP/Oxygen Ratio.
Measurement of
ADP/oxygen ratio inherently requires some degree of coupling, i.e.,
some noticeable difference between State 3 and State 4 respiration
rates. The RCR for all alkanol treatments was reduced to 1 (where State
3 rate = State 4 rate) before the inhibition of ADP/oxygen reached
50%, so we were unable to establish IC50 values
for alkanol effects on ADP/oxygen. Nevertheless, some decrease in
ADP/oxygen was evident for treatments with hexanol, octanol, and
decanol through tridecanol; at the concentration of these alkanols
that, respectively, produced 50% inhibition of RCR, we observed
approximately 10% inhibition of ADP/oxygen, i.e., relative to an
average control value of 1.75 nmol of ADP/nmol of molecular oxygen. At
alkanol concentrations causing near total loss of RCR (RCR approaching
1.1), decline in ADP/oxygen averaged approximately 25 to 40%.
Tetradecanol and pentadecanol did not affect ADP/oxygen ratios.
Inhibition of Respiration in Intact Versus Broken
Mitochondria.
In subsequent assays with independent mitochondrial
preparations, a medium- and a long-chain alkanol (hexanol and decanol) were each tested for their differential effects on the uncoupled respiration of isolated rat liver mitochondria that was 1) intact and
used immediately on isolation, or 2) subjected to two freeze-thaw cycles so as to physically break the inner and outer mitochondrial membranes. Consistent with the earlier data, both hexanol and decanol
inhibited respiration of intact mitochondria in a dose-dependent manner, but notably, each compound had far less effect on the freeze-thawed mitochondrial preparation.
Hexanol severely inhibited the respiration of intact, uncoupled
mitochondria with a concentration of 20 mM producing respiration rates
approximately 37 ± 2% of the control rate. In contrast, hexanol
had weak activity against respiration in freeze-thawed mitochondria,
with 20 mM only decreasing respiration to 83 ± 5% of controls
(Fig. 5). Even more pronounced than the
results of hexanol, 0.6 mM decanol decreased uncoupled respiration in
intact mitochondria to just 23 ± 3% of control rates, yet in
freeze-thawed mitochondria the same concentration of decanol only
decreased respiration to 90 ± 6.0%) of controls (Fig.
6).

View larger version (16K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5.
Effects of hexanol on the respiration rate of intact
(uncoupled) and freeze-thawed mitochondria isolated from rat liver.
|
|

View larger version (17K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6.
Effects of decanol on the respiration rate of intact
(uncoupled) and freeze-thawed mitochondria isolated from rat liver.
|
|
Effect of Mitochondrial Protein Concentration on Inhibition.
To gain further insight into the molecular nature of the inhibition,
several experiments were performed under identical conditions but with
half as much mitochondrial protein to initiate respiration. The results
show that for hexanol, there is a similar degree of inhibition, even
when the protein concentration is halved. The level of inhibition seems
to depend on the inhibitor concentration, regardless of how much
mitochondrial protein is present (Table 2).
For decanol, the data seem to indicate that inhibition by decanol may
depend partly on the amount of mitochondrial protein present, not soley
on the decanol concentration. However, more experiments would be
desirable before asserting any solid conclusion that the increased
inhibition seen when the alkanol concentration is held constant and the
mitochondrial protein concentration is reduced unequivocally results
from molecular mechanisms as opposed to possible variability in the data.
 |
Discussion |
The inhibitory data we report herein for alkanols of 11 carbons
and longer reflect concentrations that substantially exceed the
published aqueous solubility limits for alkanols (Bell, 1973
; Barton,
1991
). Similar findings have been reported elsewhere, for both alcohols
and acids (Huhtanen, 1980
; Takeuchi et al., 1991
; Kubo et al., 1995
;
Gustavson et al., 1998
; Matsuki et al., 1999
). Mitochondrial membranes
are composed largely of lipids, so if an aqueous assay system is
designed to create a supersaturated suspension, even temporarily, then
high doses of amphiphilic compounds may partition into the lipid
environment and thereby be delivered to the target site. A
supersaturated solution is facilitated by adding the alkanols from a
solution having detergent properties (such as DMSO), or by adding the
solution while simultaneously applying sonication. Moreover, long-chain
alcohols are known to have a marked propensity for forming
supersaturated solutions without forming micelles (Tanford, 1991
).
The concentrations found to inhibit mitochondrial respiration are
comparable with those causing death in mosquitoes and other organisms
(Fig. 7), prompting the question whether
decreased mitochondrial functions might in some way contribute to
mosquito death. If mosquito larvae were prevented from making ATP,
approximately 90% of which is produced in mitochondria, then certainly
they would appear paralyzed and, ultimately, would die. Although more
work is required to substantiate the apparent correlation, in a single
preparation of mosquito larvae mitochondria that we succeeded in
isolating, a decanol concentration of 100 µM caused approximately
30% inhibition of uncoupled respiration, which is roughly comparable
with the effects seen in rat liver mitochondria. Differences in the
chain length of cutoff from one organism to another may be related to differences in the composition of their respective cell membranes because alkanols have been shown to bind more tightly to those phospholipid vesicles having longer acyl chains (Kamaya et al., 1981
),
and increasing the cholesterol content of lipid membranes has been
shown to suppress anesthetic potency (Rehberg et al., 1995
).

View larger version (27K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 7.
The biological activity of alkanols against various
organisms in vivo compared with their inhibition of RCR in isolated rat
mitochondria. Cutoff in activity occurs at different chain lengths in
different organisms. For isolated mitochondria, tetradecanol may show
some activity if applied for longer preincubation times. , tadpole
(Rana pipiens), loss of righting reflex,
EC50 (Alifimoff et al., 1989 ); , minnow
(Pimephales promelas), 96 h LC50 (Veith
et al., 1983 ); , protozoan (Tetrahymena pyriformis),
inhibitory growth concentration, EC50 (Schultz et al.,
1990 ); , Staphylococcus aureus, minimum bactericidal
concentration, EC50 (Kubo et al., 1995 ); , isolated rat
mitochondria, respiratory control ratio, IC50; ×, mosquito
(Culex tarsalis), 24 h LD50; Tween used
to maximize solubility of alkanols 13 carbons in length (Hammond and
Kubo, 1999 ); , Propionibacteruim acnes, minimum
bactericidal concentration, EC50 (Kubo et al., 1995 ); and
+, Clostridium botulinum, minimum inhibitory
concentration (Huhtanen, 1980 ).
|
|
Independent evidence of a role for mitochondria in anesthetic action
has indeed been found. By mutating a gene of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans that has been determined to control
expression of a mitochondrial protein located within NADH dehydrogenase
of complex I, an increased sensitivity to volatile anesthetics was conferred (Kayser et al., 1999
). Although the precise function of the
gene's mitochondrial protein product has still not been identified,
Kayser et al. (1999)
found that the mutation in complex I increases the
animal's sensitivity to anesthetics, either by a direct anesthetic
effect on a mitochondrial protein or by indirect effects resulting in
mitochondrial dysfunction. Such malfunctions could result from lipid
peroxidation and membrane damage caused by depletion of the antioxidant
ubiquinol pool, or simply from lack of electrons to fuel synthesis of
ATP, the regulator of innumerable other cellular processes (Kayser et
al., 1999
).
Numerous studies have reported certain biological activities for
short-chain alcohols, and different, or even opposite, activities for
longer chain homologs. For example, patch-clamp studies on neuroblastoma cells showed that butanol and hexanol potentiated responses to the activator 5-hydroxytryptamine at low concentrations, and inhibited them at high concentrations; in contrast, higher alcohols
produced no potentiation, but only inhibition, at all alcohol
concentrations (Jenkins et al., 1996
). In studies of the effects of
alkanols on calcium transport in brain mitochondria, it was found that
short-chain alcohols inhibit whereas long-chain alcohols activate the
cyclosporin-sensitive Ca2+ efflux (Rottenberg and
Marbach, 1992
). There is convincing evidence that short-chain and
long-chain alkanols act at distinct sites on the nicotinic
acetylcholine receptor channels of electric eels, thus accounting for
their dissimilar effects on ion flux (Wood et al., 1991
, 1993
).
The finding that hexanol stimulates State 4 respiration at low
concentration, yet inhibits it at high concentrations (Fig. 2)
corroborates the results of a previous study (Canton et al., 1996
). In
intact rat mitochondria tested at 20°C, decanol inhibits uncoupled
respiration at a relatively low concentration, but hexanol inhibits it
more completely (Fig. 4). This difference between the degree of maximal
effects on mitochondria displayed by decanol and hexanol may
conceivably be a consequence of the latter acting via a wider array of
mechanisms. Nevertheless, lack of sufficient solubility probably plays
a part in explaining the limits to decanol's inhibitory effect. The
data comparing freeze-thawed and intact mitochondrial preparations
(Figs. 5 and 6), where similar assays were performed at 30°C, shows
decanol inhibiting uncoupled respiration (77%) more thoroughly than
hexanol (63%), so it is possible that the additional doses of decanol
depicted in Fig. 4 produced no additional inhibitory effect simply
because they could not enter solution. Hexanol, in contrast, is easily
soluble up to concentrations more than three times greater than any
dose tested herein (Bell, 1973
).
The fact that alkanols inhibit State 3 and uncoupled respiration while
stimulating State 4 causes the oxygen electrode trace to tend toward a
straight line at high concentrations (Fig. 4). Determining the slope of
each respiratory state under these conditions becomes somewhat
imprecise and contributes to the relatively large standard errors in
the figures.
In earlier in vivo studies of 1-alkanols as mosquito larvicidal agents,
we found that the action of chain lengths >11 carbons was clearly time
dependent, with dodecanol immobilizing mosquito larvae after 12 min,
tridecanol after 45 min, tetradecanol after 3 h, and pentadecanol
after 12 h (Hammond and Kubo, 1999
). Nonlinear data for
tetradecanol against State 3 respiration therefore leads us to
speculate that although it may indeed possess inhibitory activity, its
action is time dependent, requiring more than the 15-min preincubation
period used herein.
Where inhibition of State 3 respiration is greater than that of
uncoupled respiration at equivalent doses, one can reasonably infer
some inhibitory effect on ATP synthase (complex V) (Gudz et al., 1997
).
But the fact that inhibition by alkanols, regardless of chain length,
is nearly identical for both State 3 and uncoupled respiration (Fig.
8) implies that complex V is not directly
affected by alkanols at the concentrations used herein.

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 8.
Effects of octanol on RCR ( ), State 3 ( ), and
uncoupled respiration ( ), expressed as percentage of inhibition from
control. Other alkanols displayed similar patterns, such that State 3 and uncoupled respiration were each inhibited to a similar degree.
Curve fitting is described in Experimental Procedures.
|
|
It appears then that the inhibition occurs either at the level of the
electron transport chain and/or on the dicarboxylate substrate carrier
enzyme itself, which is needed to shuttle succinate across the inner
membrane for its introduction into the respiratory chain at complex II
(Tyler, 1992
). Our preliminary assays with duroquinol as substrate,
which feeds into complex III, suggest that there is no inhibition of
the respiratory chain by alkanols at complexes III or IV up to the
maximum doses tested herein (data not shown).
Previous work has shown that long-chain fatty acids affect
mitochondrial respiration by uncoupling State 4 and inhibiting State 3 (Takeuchi et al., 1991
), and by directly inhibiting activity of the
dicarboxylate carrier (Wieckowski and Wojtczak, 1997
). Fatty acids and
fatty alcohols, both head-tail type compounds, may share common
mechanisms for inhibiting mitochondrial respiration. Interestingly, on
several occasions we found that at a dose approximately five times the
concentration of alkanol needed to lower the RCR to 1, the
mitochondrial test solution turned from milky to clear, inhibition was
released, and respiration increased. Presumably, this occurs because on
reaching the critical micelle concentration of the alkanol, its
detergent properties serve to solubilize the mitochondrial membranes. A
finding that succinate-supported, uncoupled respiration increases after
permeabilizing the mitochondrial membrane is consistent with the
possibility that the actual site of inhibition may be the dicarboxylate
substrate carrier, and not, or not only, complex II of the electron
transport chain itself.
Effects of a compound on mitochondrial substrate carriers such as the
dicarboxylate carrier, which transports succinate, can be distinguished
from effects on the electron transport chain by the use of
freeze-thawed mitochondria (Modica-Napolitano et al., 1990
; Krahenbuhl
et al., 1991
; Modica-Napolitano, 1993
; Krahenbuhl et al., 1994
; Gudz et
al., 1997
). Because freezing to
20 or
80°C and subsequently
thawing has the consequence of breaking the inner and outer
mitochondrial membranes, substrates that would normally need to be
transported across the membrane before being fed into the respiratory
chain can instead freely access complex II. The data presented in Figs.
5 and 6, where hexanol and decanol are both shown to inhibit uncoupled
respiration in intact mitochondria but that such inhibition is released
in freeze-thawed mitochondria, indicates that the inhibitory effects
can therefore be inferred to occur at the level of trans-membrane
substrate transport rather than on the electron transport chain itself.
Researchers describing the effects of butanol, pentanol, and hexanol on
submitochondrial particles (Chazotte and Vanderkooi, 1981
) concluded
that inhibition occurs at various enzyme sites along the electron
transport chain, but at 5- to 10-fold the concentrations reported
herein. Although there is undoubtedly an effect of alkanols on electron
transport, our data show that inhibition occurs on the substrate
carrier first, and at lower concentration.
It would be interesting to see whether further experiments would
corroborate the preliminary findings of Table 2, where decanol inhibits
respiration more thoroughly in a solution containing 0.1 mg of
mitochondrial protein/ml than in one containing 0.2 mg/ml, but hexanol
inhibits them both equally. The pattern suggested is consistent with a
scenario whereby decanol acts in a specific manner, binding molecule
per molecule to a finite number of protein sites, whereas hexanol acts
as a nonspecific agent of conformational or structural changes,
probably perturbing the lipid-protein interface, but not acting via a
"lock-and-key" type molecular interaction.
We thank Drs. Vladimir Gogvadze, Patrick Walter, Hadi Moini, and
John Maguire for helpful discussions regarding mitochondrial respiration, characteristics of the respiratory chain, and
interpretation of oxygen electrode traces.
Accepted for publication February 10, 2000.
Received for publication October 6, 1999.
DMSO, dimethyl sulfoxide;
RCR, respiratory
control ratio;
CCCP, carbonyl cyanide
m-chlorophenylhydrazone.