![]() |
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Vol. 281, Issue 1, 208-217, 1997
Physiopharmacologie du Système Nerveux, l'Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale U161, and Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes, Paris, France (P.H., J.B., J.-M.B.), and Laboratoire de Pharmacochimie Moléculaire et Structurale, l'Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale U266, CNRS URA D1500, Paris, France (M.-C.F.-Z., B.P.R.)
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The effects of RB101, a complete inhibitor of enkephalin-catabolizing enzymes, alone or with a selective cholecystokinin (CCK)B receptor antagonist (CI988) or CCKA receptor antagonist (devazepide), on carrageenin-induced spinal c-Fos expression were investigated. Spinal c-Fos expression was observed 90 min after intraplantar carrageenin (6 mg/150 µl saline), with Fos-like-immunoreactive neurons preferentially located in the superficial laminae of the spinal dorsal horn. Intravenous RB101 (10, 20 and 40 mg/kg) dose-dependently reduced the number of superficial Fos-like-immunoreactive neurons (r2 = 0.739, P < .0001), with 63 ± 2% (P < .0001) reduction for the highest dose. These effects were completely blocked by coadministered naloxone. Coadministration of inactive doses of i.v. RB101 (5 mg/kg) and i.p. CI988 (3 mg/kg) significantly and strongly reduced the number of carrageenin-induced, superficial, Fos-like-immunoreactive neurons (55 ± 5% reduction of control carrageenin c-Fos expression, P < .0001). This effect was blocked by coadministered naloxone. It is important to note that coadministered RB101 and devazepide did not influence spinal c-Fos expression. None of the various drug combinations influenced the carrageenin-induced peripheral edema. These results show that RB101 dose-dependently decreases carrageenin-evoked spinal c-Fos expression. In addition, the effectiveness of RB101 can be revealed by preadministration of the CCKB receptor antagonist CI988. Considering the weak opioid side effects obtained with RB101 treatment and the strong increase of its effects by the CCKB receptor antagonist, this type of drug combination could have promising therapeutic application in the management of pain in humans.
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Neutral endopeptidase 24.11 and
aminopeptidase N are the two enzymes involved in the degradation of
enkephalins in vivo. Several inhibitors of these
zinc-metallopeptidases, selective for one enzyme or with dual
selectivity, have been designed, protecting enkephalins from catabolism
both in vitro and in vivo. These compounds have
various pharmacological properties deriving from this protection, such
as antinociceptive effects (for review, see Roques et al., 1993
). Among the designed mixed inhibitors of enkephalin
catabolism, RB101 has been shown to be able to cross the
blood-brain barrier (Fournié-Zaluski et al., 1992
),
eliciting antinociceptive effects in mice and rats after systemic
administration (Fournié-Zaluski et al., 1992
;
Maldonado et al., 1994
; Noble and Roques, 1995
; Noble
et al., 1992
).
Considerable evidence has accumulated for a role of CCK during
nociceptive transmission (see references in Baber et al.,
1989
; Stanfa et al., 1994
). CCK, which is discretely
distributed in the central nervous system (Gall et al.,
1987
; Vanderhaegen et al., 1975
), has been suggested to play
a counteracting role to endogenous opioids (Faris et al.,
1983
). CCK antagonists has been shown to potentiate the effects of
opioids (for review, see Baber et al., 1989
). The
interactions between CCK receptor antagonists and opioids for the
control of nociception are mainly mediated via
CCKB receptors (Chapman et al., 1995
; Dourish
et al., 1988
, 1990
; Maldonado et al., 1993
;
Valverde et al., 1994
; Wiesenfeld-Hallin et al.,
1990
), which are found predominantly in the central nervous system
(Hill and Woodruff, 1990
; Kopin et al., 1992
; Moran et al., 1986
; Pelaprat et al., 1987
; Wank et
al., 1992
). Furthermore, Vanderah et al. (1994)
showed
that i.c.v. treatment with a CCKB receptor antisense
oligonucleotide in mice resulted in an enhancement of the
antinociceptive effects of i.c.v. morphine. CCKB receptors are highly concentrated in laminae I and II of the rat dorsal horn of
the spinal cord, and studies with neonatal capsaicin have illustrated
that CCKB receptors are located on C primary afferent fibers and post-synaptically on dorsal horn neurons (Ghilardi et
al., 1992
). Thus, both the laminar and synaptic locations of CCK
receptors seem to be similar to those of the opioid receptors (see
references in Besse et al., 1991
; Lombard et al.,
1995
).
c-Fos expression, at the spinal level, is one of the long-term
intracellular events (for review, see Morgan, 1991
; Morgan and Curran,
1995
) that could be used as an indirect marker of nociceptive processes
(see references in Abbadie et al., 1994a
; Zieglgänsberger and Tölle, 1993
). Noxious (A
and C fiber
intensity) but not innocuous (A
/
fiber intensity) electrical
stimulation of the sciatic nerve has been shown to induce c-Fos
expression in superficial and deeper lumbar dorsal horn neurons
(Herdegen et al., 1991
). The laminar distribution of c-Fos
is in good keeping with the findings of electrophysiological studies,
which have shown that a high proportion of superficial and deep laminae
dorsal horn neurons are driven by noxious inputs (see references in
Besson and Chaouch, 1987
). Furthermore, in keeping with the evidence that spinal c-Fos is predominantly evoked by noxious stimuli, several
studies showed that preadministered morphine significantly reduced
spinal c-Fos expression induced by various types of peripheral nociceptive stimulation, such as intraplantar formalin injection (Gogas
et al., 1991
; Jasmin et al., 1994
; Presley
et al., 1990
), intraplantar carrageenin injection
(Honoré et al., 1995b
), i.p. acetic acid injection
(Hammond et al., 1992
), noxious heat (Abbadie et
al., 1994c
; Tölle et al., 1990
, 1991
, 1994a
,b
),
noxious cold (Abbadie et al., 1994b
), noxious mechanical
stimulation (Abbadie and Besson, 1993
) and chemical stimulation of the
meninges (Nozaki et al., 1992
). In agreement with a
physiological role of endogenous enkephalins in nociception control,
two previous studies demonstrated that enkephalin-catabolizing enzyme
inhibitors such as kelatorphan (Tölle et al., 1994b
)
and RB101 (Abbadie et al., 1994c
) significantly decreased
noxiously evoked spinal c-Fos expression.
We previously showed that the effects of low doses of i.v. morphine on
noxiously induced spinal c-Fos expression could be revealed by
coadministration of a CCKB receptor antagonist (Chapman et al., 1995
). Because CCKB receptor
antagonists, such as CI988 (Hughes et al., 1990
), have also
been shown to potentiate the antinociceptive effects of RB101
(Maldonado et al., 1993
; Noble et al., 1993
;
Valverde et al., 1994
), it was interesting to investigate whether this positive interaction could be reflected by modifications of the spinal expression of the immediate-early gene protein product c-Fos. For this purpose, the effects of various doses of i.v. RB101 on
carrageenin-induced spinal c-Fos expression have been investigated. In
the second part of our study, we have evaluated the effect of an
ineffective dose of i.v. RB101, administered with an ineffective dose
of i.p. CI988, on carrageenin-induced spinal c-Fos expression. To
further improve our results, we have studied the effects of
coadministered RB101 and devazepide, a CCKA receptor
antagonist. In these studies, we have used the intraplantar injection
of carrageenin (Winter et al., 1962
) in rats, which induces
increased induction of c-fos mRNA and expression of c-Fos protein in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord (Draisci and Iadarola, 1989
; Honoré et al., 1995a
,b
; Noguchi et
al., 1991
, 1992
) and which produces acute restricted inflammation
associated with thermal and mechanical hyperalgesia (Hargreaves
et al., 1988
; Iadarola et al., 1988
; Joris
et al., 1990
; Kayser and Guilbaud, 1987
). Part of this study
has been previously presented as an abstract (Honoré et
al., 1996
).
| |
Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Experimental animals.
Experiments were performed on 90 adult, male, albino, Sprague-Dawley rats (Charles River, France),
weighing 225 to 250 g. Guidelines on ethical standards for
investigations of experimental pain in conscious animals were followed
(Zimmermann, 1983
). Rats were kept in an animal room at a constant
temperature of 22°C, with a 12-hr alternating light/dark cycle.
Chemicals.
RB101
[N-[(RS)-2-benzyl-3[(S)-(2-amino-4-methylthio)butyldithio]-1-oxopropyl]-L-phenylalanine
benzyl ester] and CI988 [PD 134,308 or
4-{[2-[[3-(1H-indol-3-yl)-2-methyl-1-oxo-2-[[tricyclo[3,3,1,137]dec-2-yloxycarbonyl]amino]propyl]amino]-1-phenylethyl]amin}-4-oxo-[R-(R*,R*)]butanoate-N-methyl-D-glucamine] were synthesized as previously described (Fournié-Zaluski
et al., 1992
; Hughes et al., 1990
). Naloxone was
purchased from DuPont de Nemours France (naloxone hydrochloride,
injectable solution, 0.4 mg/ml). Devazepide (L364,718) was prepared in
Tween 80 (0.1%; Sigma). RB101 was dissolved in ethanol (10%),
Cremofor EL (10%) and distilled water. CI988 was prepared in an
aqueous suspension with carboxymethylcellulose (0.5%, sodium salt;
Sigma).
Experimental protocol.
Intraplantar carrageenin (6 mg, in
150 µl of saline) was injected in the hind limb and rats were
perfused 90 min after this injection, a delay which has been shown to
evoke c-Fos expression in numerous neurons in the dorsal horn of the
spinal cord (Honoré et al., 1995b
). In this study,
nonstimulated control animals and control animals receiving an
intraplantar injection of saline were not included, because we
previously showed that in these two groups almost no c-Fos labeling
(<5 Fos-LI neurons/section) was observed at the level of the spinal
cord (Honoré et al., 1995a
). The delay of 90 min was
also chosen according to the duration of action of RB101 (Noble
et al., 1992
). In that study, Noble et al. (1992)
investigated the effects of RB101 in numerous analgesic tests, such as
the hot-plate and phenylbenzoquinone-induced abdominal constriction
tests in mice and the tail-flick and electric stimulation tests in
rats. They showed that the duration of action of RB101 is approximately
1 hr. In our study, we have chosen to observe spinal c-Fos expression
90 min after carrageenin injection, which, due to the delay in protein
expression, reflects the situation at least 30 min earlier.
Immunohistochemistry. At 90 min after intraplantar carrageenin injection, the animals were deeply anaesthetized with pentobarbital (55 mg/kg i.p.; Sanofi) and perfused intracardially with 200 ml of PBS, followed by 500 ml of 4% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M PB. The spinal cord was then removed, postfixed for 4 hr in the same fixative and cryoprotected overnight in 30% sucrose in PB. Frontal frozen sections (40 µm thick) were cut and collected in PB to be processed immunohistochemically as free-floating sections.
The serial sections from the lumbar segment were immunostained for c-Fos-like protein according to the avidin-biotin-peroxidase method (Hsu et al., 1981Counting of c-Fos-labeled neurons.
Tissue sections were
first examined using dark-field microscopy to determine the segmental
level, according to the method of Molander et al. (1984)
, as
well as the gray matter landmarks. The sections were then examined
under light-field microscopy at ×10 magnification to localize
c-Fos-positive cells. Labeled nuclei were counted using a camera lucida
attachment. To study the laminar distribution, four regions were
defined, as follows: superficial dorsal horn (laminae I and II;
superficial), nucleus proprius (laminae III and IV; nucleus proprius),
neck of the dorsal horn (laminae V and VI; neck) and the ventral gray
(laminae VII-X; ventral).
Evaluation of inflammation.
To assess the level of the
peripheral inflammation, we considered two indicators of peripheral
edema, i.e., paw diameter (the measure of the edema of the
site of inflammatory stimulation with intraplantar injection of
carrageenin) and ankle diameter (the measure of the extension of the
edema). For each rat one measure of both paw and ankle diameters was
performed with a caliper square immediately before perfusion.
Carrageenin-enhanced paw and ankle diameters of the control group of
rats (Pc and Ac,
respectively) and the drug-treated rats (Pt and
At, respectively) were measured. For comparison,
paw and ankle diameters of nonstimulated rats (Pn and An, respectively)
were measured. The carrageenin-induced paw and ankle diameters were
determined as the difference between the paw and ankle diameters of
carrageenin-stimulated and nonstimulated rats. The effects of drugs
were determined as percent changes of the carrageenin-induced paw and
ankle diameters of drug-treated rats (Pt
Pn and At
An, respectively), compared with the paw and
ankle diameters of control carrageenin-treated rats
(Pc
Pn and
Ac
An, respectively);
the following formulae were used were used: for the paw diameter,
[(Pt
Pn)/(Pc
Pn)] × 100; for the ankle diameter,
[(At
An)/(Ac
An)] × 100. Studies of carrageenin-evoked
spinal c-Fos-LI neurons and peripheral edema were performed in the same
rats; therefore, possible correlations between the parameters were
determined.
Statistical tests. Statistical analysis was performed to compare the total number of Fos-LI neurons, using one-way analysis of variance for the different groups of animals and two-way analysis of variance for the different groups of animals and the laminar region. To compare the ankle or paw diameters, we used one-way analysis of variance for the different groups of animals. For multiple comparisons, the Fisher's protected least-significant difference test was used. Linear regression was used for dose-dependent effects of RB101 on a single parameter. The investigator responsible for plotting and counting the Fos-LI neurons was blind to the experimental conditions for each animal.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In nonstimulated rats receiving i.v. RB101 (40 mg/kg), extremely
low numbers of Fos-LI neurons were observed in the dorsal horn of the
lumbar spinal cord (1-3 Fos-LI neurons/L4 and L5 40-µm section).
Ninety minutes after intraplantar carrageenin, Fos-LI nuclei, which
were stained to a variable degree, were located in the ipsilateral
dorsal horn of the spinal cord. All Fos-LI nuclei were analyzed without
considering the intensity of the staining. In agreement with previous
studies on intraplantar carrageenin-evoked spinal c-Fos expression
(Honoré et al., 1995a
), Fos-LI neurons were observed
in lumbar segments L2 to L6, with maximal labeling in segments L4 and
L5.
Effects of RB101 on Carrageenin-induced c-Fos Expression and Peripheral Edema
c-Fos expression. In the first experimental series, the total number of Fos-LI neurons observed 90 min after carrageenin was 59 ± 3 Fos-LI neurons/40-µm section, in segments L4 and L5. The Fos-LI neurons were preferentially located in the superficial laminae (I and II) of the dorsal horn (86 ± 3%), whereas fewer neurons were observed in the nucleus proprius (1 ± 1%), the deep laminae (V and VI; 8 ± 2%) and the ventral horn (4 ± 1%) of the spinal cord.
Intravenous RB101 dose-dependently reduced the number of superficial Fos-LI neurons (r2 = 0.739, P < .0001) (figs. 1 and 2; for percentages, see table 1). In addition, i.v. naloxone, which had no effect when administered alone (92 ± 3% of control carrageenin expression), completely blocked the effects of the highest dose of i.v. RB101 (40 mg/kg) on the number of superficial Fos-LI neurons (no difference from the control group) (fig. 1B; table 1); the lack of effect of coadministered i.v. naloxone and RB101 on the number of superficial Fos-LI neurons (96 ± 3% of control carrageenin expression) was significantly different from the effect of 40 mg/kg i.v. RB101 injected alone (P < .0001) (fig. 1B).
|
|
|
Peripheral edema. We observed the development of unilateral peripheral edema associated with the intraplantar injection of carrageenin. Both the paw and ankle diameters of the injected hind paw were increased (181 ± 5% and 118 ± 2% of nonstimulated rat paw and ankle diameters, respectively), whereas the contralateral hind paw was unaffected (105 ± 0% and 98 ± 1% of nonstimulated rat paw and ankle diameters, respectively). Neither RB101, naloxone nor coadministered RB101 and naloxone influenced the carrageenin-induced peripheral edema.
Effects of the Coadministration of RB101 and CI988, a CCKB Receptor Antagonist, on Carrageenin-induced c-Fos Expression and Peripheral Edema
c-Fos expression. In the second experimental series, the total number of Fos-LI neurons observed 90 min after carrageenin was 98 ± 3 Fos-LI neurons/section, in segments L4 and L5. The Fos-LI neurons were preferentially located in the superficial laminae (I and II) of the dorsal horn (66 ± 1%), whereas fewer neurons were observed in the nucleus proprius (3 ± 1%), the deep laminae (V and VI; 24 ± 3%) and the ventral horn (7 ± 1%) of the spinal cord.
Prior administration of RB101 (5 mg/kg i.v.) or CI988 (3 mg/kg i.p.) was ineffective at reducing the number of spinal Fos-LI neurons induced at 90 min after intraplantar carrageenin (fig. 3; table 2). However, prior coadministration of RB101 (5 mg/kg) and CI988 (3 mg/kg) significantly, and strongly, reduced the total number of spinal Fos-LI neurons induced at 90 min after intraplantar carrageenin (59 ± 5% reduction of control carrageenin spinal c-Fos expression, P < .0001). These effects were essentially observed at the level of the superficial laminae (55 ± 5% reduction of control carrageenin spinal c-Fos expression, P < .0001). In addition, these effects were significantly different from the lack of effect of RB101 injected alone (P < .0001) and CI988 injected alone (P < .0001) (fig. 3; table 2). Furthermore, the significant reduction of c-Fos expression by coadministered RB101 and CI988 was significantly blocked by the additional administration of naloxone (P < .0001 between the effects of RB101 plus CI988 and the lack of effect of RB101 plus CI988 plus naloxone), which had no effect when injected alone (fig. 3; table 2). In addition, higher doses of CI988 (6 and 9 mg/kg i.p.) injected alone did not influence carrageenin-induced spinal c-Fos expression (table 3).
|
|
|
Peripheral edema. Again, unilateral peripheral edema was associated with the intraplantar injection of carrageenin. Both the paw and ankle diameters of the injected hind paw were increased (189 ± 4% and 118 ± 2% of nonstimulated rat paw and ankle diameters, respectively), whereas the contralateral hind paw was unaffected (105 ± 0% and 100 ± 1% of nonstimulated rat paw and ankle diameters, respectively). None of the various drug combinations influenced the carrageenin-induced peripheral edema.
Lack of Effect of the Coadministration of RB101 and Devazepide, a CCKA Receptor Antagonist, on Carrageenin-induced c-Fos Expression and Peripheral Edema
c-Fos expression. In the third experimental series, the total number of Fos-LI neurons observed 90 min after carrageenin was 102 ± 5 Fos-LI neurons/section, in segments L4 and L5. The Fos-LI neurons were preferentially located in the superficial laminae (I and II) of the dorsal horn (58 ± 2%), whereas fewer neurons were observed in the nucleus proprius (6 ± 1%), the deep laminae (V and VI; 28 ± 2%) and the ventral horn (8 ± 1%) of the spinal cord.
Prior administration of RB101 (5 mg/kg i.v.) or devazepide (0.1 mg/kg i.p.) was ineffective at reducing the number of spinal Fos-LI neurons induced at 90 min after intraplantar carrageenin (table 3). In addition, prior coadministration of RB101 (5 mg/kg) and devazepide (0.1 mg/kg) did not influence spinal c-Fos expression induced at 90 min after intraplantar carrageenin (table 4).
|
Peripheral edema. Again, unilateral peripheral edema was associated with the intraplantar injection of carrageenin. Both the paw and ankle diameters of the injected hind paw were increased (181 ± 5% and 113 ± 0% of nonstimulated rat paw and ankle diameters, respectively), whereas the contralateral hind paw was unaffected (101 ± 2% and 97 ± 0% of nonstimulated rat paw and ankle diameters, respectively). None of the various drug combinations influenced the carrageenin-induced peripheral edema.
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the present study, we have demonstrated that RB101, a
complete inhibitor of enkephalin-catabolizing enzymes
(Fournié-Zaluski et al., 1992
), dose-dependently
decreases carrageenin-induced spinal c-Fos expression, in a
naloxone-reversible manner. In addition, we have shown that CI988, a
CCKB receptor antagonist, reveals the antinociceptive
effects of an inactive dose of RB101, in a naloxone-reversible manner.
Furthermore, none of the drug combinations influenced the peripheral
edema, suggesting that this interaction takes place at spinal or
supraspinal levels.
Numerous Fos-LI neurons were observed, mainly in the superficial
laminae of the dorsal horn of the L4 and L5 spinal segments, 90 min
after intraplantar carrageenin injection. Both the laminar and
rostrocaudal distributions of Fos-LI neurons after intraplantar carrageenin are in good agreement with our previous study (Honoré et al., 1995b
). Indeed, in the latter study, we showed that,
after intraplantar carrageenin injection, spinal c-Fos expression was observed mainly in the superficial laminae during the first 90 min
after carrageenin injection. At later time points, c-Fos expression in
deeper spinal laminae was detectable, i.e., at 2 hr after
carrageenin injection, and an equal repartition of spinal Fos-LI
neurons between superficial and deep laminae was observed at 3 hr after
carrageenin (Honoré et al., 1995a
,b
). The total number
of Fos-LI neurons observed in the two control carrageenin-treated
groups was different in the two experimental series. Such variations
are presumably due to the inherent variability among experimental
series associated with this immunohistochemical technique. Overall, in
the same experimental series, the data were very homogeneous, allowing the statistical analysis of the drug effects.
Administration of RB101 (10, 20 or 40 mg/kg i.v.), 10 min before
intraplantar carrageenin injection, significantly and dose-dependently reduced the number of spinal Fos-LI neurons observed 90 min after intraplantar carrageenin injection, in a naloxone-reversible manner, and i.v. RB101 (40 mg/kg) did not induce spinal c-Fos expression in
nonstimulated rats. Our results are in good agreement with previous
studies, which showed that systemic enkephalin-catabolizing enzyme
inhibitors such as kelatorphan (Tölle et al., 1994b
)
and RB101 (Abbadie et al., 1994c
) dose-dependently reduced
noxious heat-evoked spinal c-Fos expression, in a naloxone-reversible manner. Furthermore, our results are reminiscent of behavioral (Fournié-Zaluski et al., 1984
, 1985
, 1992
; Kayser
et al., 1989
; Maldonado et al., 1993
, 1994
; Noble
and Roques, 1995
; Noble et al., 1992
; Perrot et
al., 1993
; Schmidt et al., 1991
; Valverde et
al., 1994
) and electrophysiological (Dickenson et al.,
1987
; Morton et al., 1987
; Stanfa and Dickenson, 1994
;
Sullivan et al., 1989
) studies, which showed that various
enkephalin-catabolizing enzyme inhibitors exerted antinociceptive
effects in animals (for review, see Roques et al., 1993
). In
the present study, none of the tested doses of RB101 reduced the
development of the peripheral edema, suggesting that the effects of
this compound observed in this study are mainly due to a spinal and/or
supraspinal site of action. However, we cannot totally exclude a
peripheral site of action, because the antinociceptive effects of
systemic RB101 on responses to noxious pressure of the hind paw in rats
with local inflammation are partially blocked by the administration of
methylnaloxonium, which does not cross the blood-brain barrier (Maldonado et al., 1994
).
Administration of the CCKB receptor antagonist CI988 alone
did not influence the number of spinal Fos-LI neurons observed after
intraplantar carrageenin injection, even with very high doses. This
result suggests that CCK itself does not influence the overall level of
c-Fos expression evoked by intraplantar carrageenin and that CCK
systems do not tonically influence nociceptive processing in this
model. Our results are in good agreement with previous studies, which
also showed that CCK receptor antagonists are without effect on
nociceptive processes when administered alone (Chapman et
al., 1995
; Dourish et al., 1988
, 1990
; Kellstein and
Mayer, 1990
; Magnuson et al., 1990
; Maldonado et
al., 1993
; Noble et al., 1995
; Ossipov et
al., 1994
; Stanfa and Dickenson, 1993
; Valverde et al.,
1994
; Watkins et al., 1985
; Zhou et al., 1993
).
Furthermore, it has been shown that, under nonpathological conditions,
the amount of spinal CCK released is very low (Zhou et al.,
1993
). However, CI988 has been shown to display significant
antinociceptive effects after peripheral nerve injury (Xu et
al., 1994a
) and to relieve allodynia-like symptoms (Xu et
al., 1994b
). Thus, further studies would be necessary to determine
whether there is a differential effect of CCKB receptor
antagonists on inflammatory pain vs. neuropathic pain.
Coadministration of inactive doses of RB101 and the selective
CCKB receptor antagonist CI988 significantly and strongly
(59 ± 5% reduction) reduced the carrageenin-evoked spinal c-Fos
expression, whereas coadministered RB101 and devazepide (a selective
CCKA receptor antagonist) did not influence spinal c-Fos
expression. Interestingly, the peripheral edema was not influenced by
coadministered RB101 and CI988, suggesting that the location of the
potentiation between the effects of RB101 and CI988 is at the level of
the spinal cord and/or higher brain structures, although we cannot exclude a peripheral effect. Our results are reminiscent of previous studies, which provided evidence for spinal (Ossipov et al.,
1994
; Stanfa and Dickenson, 1993
; Wiesenfeld-Hallin and Duranti, 1987
; Wiesenfeld-Hallin et al., 1990
; Zhou et al.,
1993
) and supraspinal (Noble et al., 1993
; Pu et
al., 1994
) sites for the potentiation between opioids and
CCKB receptor antagonists. It must be also emphasized that,
in the present study, the effects of the combination of
CCKB receptor antagonist plus RB101 were mainly studied in the superficial dorsal horn of the spinal cord (laminae I and II),
which is the main terminal site of nociceptive primary afferent fibers,
which contains almost exclusively neurons receiving noxious inputs
(laminae I and II outer) (Besson and Chaouch, 1987
) and which is
extremely rich in opioid receptors, endogenous opioids (see references
in Basbaum and Besson, 1991
) and CCKB receptors (Ghilardi
et al., 1992
). Thus, the use of this new experimental strategy, the "c-Fos strategy," confirms the role of the
superficial dorsal horn in nociceptive processes and shows that, at
this level, various neurotransmitters involved in pain mechanisms bind
to different receptor classes so that some of them interact
synergistically and others interact antagonistically, which is the case
for endogenous opioids and CCK.
This potentiation is in agreement with the well-documented potentiation
between morphine and CCKB receptor antagonists, as shown by
behavioral and electrophysiological experiments (Dourish et
al., 1988
, 1990
; Ossipov et al., 1994
; Stanfa and
Dickenson, 1993
; Wiesenfeld-Hallin et al., 1990
; Xu et
al., 1994a
,b
; Zhou et al., 1993
). It is interesting to
note that Stanfa and Dickenson (1993)
showed that, during carrageenin
inflammation, a CCKB receptor antagonist was unable to
increase the effects of morphine. However, the action of morphine is
enhanced in inflamed rats even without CCK B receptor
antagonists; this may be due to a decrease in CCK at the spinal level,
which could also explain the lack of interaction between
CCKB receptor antagonists and morphine. In our study, the
experimental conditions were different, because drugs were injected
before the injection of carrageenin and covered the early stages of
inflammation, during which CCK was not decreased, allowing us to
observe an effect of the CCKB receptor antagonist on the effects of RB101. Similarly, using noxiously evoked spinal c-Fos expression, a CCKB receptor antagonist was shown to
increase the antinociceptive effects of morphine (Chapman et
al., 1995
). In the present study, we also demonstrated that there
is a good relationship between previous behavioral studies (Maldonado
et al., 1993
; Valverde et al., 1994
; but see
Noble et al., 1995
) and the effects of coadministration of
RB101 and a CCKB receptor antagonist on noxiously evoked
spinal c-Fos expression. In their behavioral studies, Valverde et
al. (1994)
suggested that the effectiveness of the antinociceptive responses induced by the coadministration of CCKB receptor
antagonist and RB101 is greater than that observed by other groups with
CCKB receptor antagonists and morphine. However, it is
difficult to compare our present data with those previously obtained
(Chapman et al., 1995
) on the effects of a CCKB
receptor antagonist and morphine on noxiously evoked spinal c-Fos
expression. Indeed, in the latter experiment, the effects of
coadministered morphine and CCKB receptor antagonist were
not gauged at the time point corresponding to the peak effect of
morphine (90 min to 2 hr) (Honoré et al., 1995b
), as
in the present study with coadministered RB101 and CCKB
receptor antagonist. However, the considerable decrease of noxiously
evoked spinal c-Fos expression we observed at the superficial level
suggests that the use of such drug associations to address cooperative
interactions between drugs could be very promising for the relief of
pain.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We gratefully acknowledge Dr. V. Chapman for English revision of the manuscript.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Accepted for publication December 18, 1996.
Received for publication July 22, 1996.
1 This study was supported by l'Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale and by a European Economic Community contract (BMH4-CT95.0172) on "Chronic Pain: Toward New Therapeutic Approaches."
Send reprint requests to: Prisca Honoré, INSERM U161, 2 rue d'Alésia, 75014 Paris, France.
| |
Abbreviations |
|---|
CCK, cholecystokinin; Fos-LI, Fos-like immunoreactive/immunoreactivity; PB, phosphate buffer; PBS, 0.1 M phosphate buffer plus 0.9% saline; NGST, normal goat serum in 0.1 M phosphate buffer plus 0.9% saline with 0.3% Triton-X.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
and
opioid binding sites in the superficial dorsal horn, over the rostrocaudal axis of the rat spinal cord.
Brain Res.
548: 287-291, 1991[Medline].
opioid antinociception in the rat spinal cord.
Neuropeptides
16: 213-218, 1990[Medline].
-opioid receptor-mediated antinociception in the formalin test.
Eur. J. Pharmacol.
273: 145-151, 1995[Medline].
antagonist, blocks the enhancement of morphine-antinociception induced by a CCKB antagonist in the rat.
Neurosci. Lett.
181: 9-12, 1994[Medline].
opioid mediated inhibitions of acute and prolonged noxious-evoked responses in rat dorsal horn neurones.
Br. J. Pharmacol.
98: 1039-1049, 1989[Medline].