![]() |
|
|
Vol. 280, Issue 2, 820-828, 1997
Research Service, Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center and Department of Behavioral Neuroscience, Oregon Health Sciences University, Portland, Oregon
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Recent work found that lower endogenous levels of the
-aminobutyric
acid-agonist, neuroactive steroid 3
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one (3
,5
-THP) may be correlated with increased ethanol withdrawal severity in the selectively bred Withdrawal Seizure-Prone and -Resistant mice. The present studies were conducted to determine whether decreased sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP was correlated with ethanol withdrawal hyperexcitability in another genetic mouse model,
namely the C57BL/6 (B6) and DBA/2 (D2) inbred strains. These strains
also differ in ethanol withdrawal severity (D2
B6). B6 and D2
male mice were injected with 3
,5
-THP (0-10 mg/kg i.p.) 15 min
before the timed tail vein infusion of pentylenetetrazol. B6 mice were
more sensitive than D2 animals to the anticonvulsant effect of
3
,5
-THP. Subsequent studies measured sensitivity to several of
the pharmacological effects of 3
,5
-THP. B6 and D2 male mice were
injected with 3
,5
-THP (0-32 mg/kg) before testing for locomotor
activation (total number of entries) and anxiolysis (percent open arm
entries) on the elevated plus maze, muscle relaxation (impairment of
forelimb grip strength), ataxia (impairment of Rotarod performance) and
seizure susceptibility to pentylenetetrazol. B6 mice were more
sensitive than D2 animals to the anxiolytic, locomotor stimulant and
anticonvulsant effects of 3
,5
-THP. In contrast, D2 mice were more
sensitive than B6 mice to 3
,5
-THP-induced muscle relaxation and
ataxia. Plasma 3
,5
-THP levels did not differ in the B6 and D2
mice injected with this steroid, suggesting that the strain differences
were not pharmacokinetic. Collectively, the results in selectively bred
Withdrawal Seizure-Prone and -Resistant mice and B6 and D2 inbred
strains suggest that genetic differences in neuroactive steroid
sensitivity and biosynthesis may contribute to ethanol withdrawal
severity.
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sex steroids were reported to
influence brain excitability as long ago as 1942 (Seyle, 1942
).
However, it was not until 1984 that the synthetic steroid alphaxalone
(3
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-11,20-dione) was electrophysiologically
demonstrated to potentiate GABA-gated chloride conductance (Harrison
and Simmonds, 1984
). Subsequent studies determined that the
progesterone metabolite 3
,5
-THP and the deoxycorticosterone
metabolite 3
,5
-THDOC were potent GABA-agonist modulators of the
GRC via a stereospecific interaction at a unique steroid
recognition site associated with the GRC (for reviews, see Belelli
et al., 1990
; Paul and Purdy, 1992
; Lambert et
al., 1995
). Both 3
,5
-THP and 3
,5
-THDOC enhance
GABA-stimulated chloride uptake in rat brain synaptoneurosomes at
nanomolar concentrations (Morrow et al., 1987
) and interact
with the known sites on the GRC in a noncompetitive manner (for review,
see Belelli et al., 1990
). These in vitro
demonstrations provide evidence that some steroid metabolites have
rapid membrane actions that are distinct from the genomic action of
"classical" steroid hormones.
Consistent with their GABA-agonist pharmacological profiles, exogenous
administration of 3
,5
-THP or 3
,5
-THDOC produces anesthetic
(Mok et al., 1991
), hypnotic (Mendelson et al.,
1987
), anticonvulsant (Belelli et al., 1989
; Finn and Gee,
1994
) and anxiolytic (Crawley et al., 1986
; Bitran et
al., 1991
; Weiland et al., 1995
) effects. Both
3
,5
-THP and 3
,5
-THDOC, as well as the synthetic steroid
anesthetic alphaxalone, were potent anxiolytics in several animal
models of anxiety, i.e., the light/dark transition test
(Crawley et al., 1986
; Weiland et al., 1995
), the
open field test (Weiland et al., 1991
), the conflict test
(Crawley et al., 1986
; Britton et al., 1991
;
Weiland et al., 1995
) and the elevated plus maze (Bitran
et al., 1991
; Britton et al., 1991
). In addition, 3
,5
-THP was anticonvulsant against PTZ-, (+)-bicuculline- and picrotoxin-induced seizures, with maximum potency against
(+)-bicuculline-induced convulsions (Belelli et al., 1989
).
These behavioral responses closely follow the anticipated
pharmacological patterns based on in vitro evidence.
Recent work has demonstrated that endogenous 3
,5
-THP can reach
pharmacologically relevant concentrations (Paul and Purdy, 1992
). After
swim stress in male rats and during the estrus cycle in female rats,
brain 3
,5
-THP levels increased to approximately 10 to 30 nM.
Plasma 3
,5
-THP levels also reached 100 nM during the third
trimester of pregnancy. These concentrations achieved in
vivo have been shown to potentiate the action of GABA by in vitro studies. Therefore, the available evidence suggests, but does not prove, that fluctuations in endogenous GABAergic steroids can
modify the functioning of central GABAA receptors in
vivo.
Based on recent results from our laboratory, we believed that one way
to provide support for the hypothesis that 3
,5
-THP represented a
physiologically significant endogenous neuromodulator would be to
demonstrate that lower endogenous levels of, or decreased sensitivity
to, 3
,5
-THP were correlated with genetic differences in basal or
ethanol withdrawal hyperexcitability. The B6 and D2 inbred strains
differ in a number of behaviors, including locomotor and exploratory
activity (Lhotellier et al., 1993
), learning and memory
(Fordyce and Wehner, 1993
; Rossi-Arnaud and Ammassari-Teule, 1994
),
anxiety (Trullas and Skolnick, 1993
) and seizure susceptibility (Kosobud and Crabbe, 1990
; Ferraro et al., 1995
). When
tested for susceptibility to a number of convulsants, B6 mice are
generally very seizure resistant, in comparison with other inbred
strains, whereas D2 animals are relatively seizure prone (Kosobud and
Crabbe, 1990
). B6 and D2 mice also differ markedly in many
ethanol-related behaviors, of which ethanol preference, ethanol-induced
locomotor activation and ethanol withdrawal severity are the most
notable (for review, see Phillips and Crabbe, 1991
). D2 mice exhibit
more severe handling-induced convulsions than do B6 animals after
withdrawal from both acute (Roberts et al., 1992
) and
chronic (Crabbe et al., 1983
) ethanol administration.
Therefore, B6 and D2 mice represent useful animal models to test the
hypothesis that genetic differences in the modulatory effects of
3
,5
-THP on ethanol withdrawal severity might result from
differences in 3
,5
-THP sensitivity or biosynthesis.
Preliminary results suggested that B6 and D2 mice do not differ in
biosynthesis of 3
,5
-THP after 24-hr exposure to ethanol vapor
(Finn et al., 1995a
). In both B6 and D2 mice, plasma
3
,5
-THP levels were unchanged during peak ethanol withdrawal and
were increased in only the animals that were scored hourly for
withdrawal. Therefore, the present studies were conducted to test the
hypothesis that differences in 3
,5
-THP sensitivity may contribute
to ethanol withdrawal hyperexcitability differences in B6 and D2
animals (i.e., B6 and D2 mice would differ in sensitivity to
3
,5
-THP in a manner that was consistent with their genetic
difference in ethanol withdrawal severity). Because ethanol withdrawal
is characterized by multiple behavioral changes in addition to
convulsions, a number of other behaviors were evaluated,
i.e., anxiolytic effects and locomotor activity (measured on
an elevated plus maze), ataxic effects (measured by Rotarod
performance), muscle relaxation (measured in a test of grip strength)
and anticonvulsant effects (measured by tail vein infusion of PTZ), to
determine whether a difference between B6 and D2 mice in sensitivity to
3
,5
-THP could be generalized to all pharmacological properties of
3
,5
-THP.
| |
Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Subjects
Drug-naive male B6 and D2 mice were used in all experiments. The animals were purchased from The Jackson Laboratory (Bar Harbor, ME) at 5 to 6 weeks of age, housed four per cage with ad libitum access to food and water and acclimated to a 12/12-hr light/dark cycle for a minimum of 1 week before experimentation. All procedures adhered to the United States Public Health Service/National Institutes of Health Guidelines for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals and were approved by two local institutional Animal Care and Use Committees.
Experiment 1: Anticonvulsant Sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP
The anticonvulsant effect of 3
,5
-THP was measured by
administering 3
,5
-THP (5 or 10 mg/kg) or an equivalent volume of vehicle (20% w/v 2-hydroxypropyl-
-cyclodextrin; Research
Biochemicals International, Natick, MA) by i.p. injection 15 min before
timed tail vein infusion of PTZ (5 mg/ml in saline, 0.5 ml/min; Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO). The 3
,5
-THP was prepared as a 0.5 or 1.0 mg/ml solution in 20% 2-hydroxypropyl-
-cyclodextrin and
injected in a volume of 0.01 ml/g body weight. The apparatus and
procedure for tail vein infusion have been described in detail (Kosobud
and Crabbe, 1990
). The infusion was terminated when the animals
exhibited THE. The animals were euthanized by decapitation, and trunk
blood was collected for subsequent analysis of plasma 3
,5
-THP
concentration by RIA.
The convulsion end-points are described in detail elsewhere (Kosobud
and Crabbe, 1990
). Briefly, clonus indicates rapid rhythmic movements
due to alternating contraction and relaxation of muscles, whereas tonus
indicates rigidity due to contraction of muscles. Four convulsion
signs, which occur in progression, characterize PTZ-induced
convulsions, i.e., MC twitch (sudden involuntary muscle jerks), FF clonus (rapid writhing movements of the head and neck and
forelimb clonus), RB clonus (violent whole-body clonus, including running and explosive jumps) and THE (extreme rigidity, with forelimbs and hindlimbs extended caudally). Latency to each sign was recorded in
seconds and subsequently converted to threshold convulsant dosage
(i.e., milligrams of drug per kilogram of body weight).
Experiment 2: Behavioral Sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP
We recently established a procedure for measuring a series of
behaviors, taking advantage of our experience with the individual behavioral protocols and validating the accuracy of repeated testing of
individual animals (E. J. Gallaher, unpublished observations). The
anticonvulsant effect of 3
,5
-THP was reexamined in this study for
two reasons; 1) an expanded dose range was evaluated and 2) the timed
tail vein infusion of PTZ occurred at the end of this series of
behavioral tests, so that comparisons between experiments would yield a
measure of the reliability of repeated behavioral testing in a single
animal.
Each mouse was pretested for forelimb grip strength (three trials; time
20 min) and Rotarod baseline performance (three trials; time
10
min) and then weighed and injected with 3
,5
-THP (0, 1, 3.2, 10, 17 or 32 mg/kg in 20% 2-hydroxypropyl-
-cyclodextrin i.p.) at time
0. At time +20 min the mouse was placed on the plus maze for a 5-min
trial. Total arm entries (locomotor activation) and percent open arm
entries (anxiolysis) were recorded. At time +30 min the mouse was
tested for forelimb grip strength (compared with base- line). At time
+40 min the mouse was tested for impairment on the accelerating Rotarod
(compared with baseline). At time +50 min the mouse was infused,
via a lateral tail vein, with the convulsant PTZ and was
observed for latency to MC twitch, FF clonus, RB clonus and THE. The
threshold dose of PTZ for each sign was calculated from the infusion
rate, body weight and latency. The infusion was terminated when the
animals exhibited THE or at 4 min (in cases where the mice were
protected by 3
,5
-THP). The animal was then euthanized by
decapitation, and trunk blood was collected for subsequent analysis of
plasma 3
,5
-THP concentration by RIA.
Behavioral Assessments
Muscle relaxation.
In this test, mice are placed on a tray,
allowed to grasp a horizontal bar connected to a strain gauge and then
pulled gently until they lose their grip. For comparative purposes,
grip strength decreases in a dose-dependent manner after graded doses
of chlordiazepoxide (3, 9 and 27 mg/kg) and phenobarbital (20, 40 and
80 mg/kg). The lowest doses produce a 10 to 20% decrease in grip
strength and the higher doses a 50 to 60% decrease (Meyer et
al., 1979
).
Ataxia.
The Rotarod test for ataxia was first described by
Dunham and Miya (1957)
. The Rotarod is a horizontal rotating dowel (5 cm in diameter) suspended 60 cm above a bed of sawdust. It is divided into six segments (10.2-cm wide) by means of opaque white disks 28 cm
in diameter. The surface of the dowel is covered with 320-grit, wet-dry
sandpaper to ensure a uniform surface. Typically, mice are placed on
the Rotarod and observed for ability to remain on the dowel as it
turns. In the present experiment, each mouse was placed on a stationary
Rotarod, which began to accelerate linearly (20 rpm/min) until the
mouse fell off. The latency to fall was then used to calculate the
speed (rpm) at which the mouse could no longer remain on the Rotarod.
This procedure allowed each mouse to be tested for baseline ability.
The drug effect was then expressed as a change from baseline ability.
Anxiolysis.
The animal model of anxiety that was used was
the elevated plus maze method (Pellow et al., 1985
; Lister,
1987
; Trullas and Skolnick, 1993
; Cole and Rodgers, 1994
), which is
based on a rodent's natural avoidance of open elevated alleys
(Montgomery, 1958
). The elevated plus maze consists of two open and two
enclosed horizontal perpendicular arms extending from a central
platform (5 × 5 cm), 50 cm above the floor. Each mouse was placed
on the central platform and allowed to explore freely for 5 min. During
the 5-min test period, the number of entries into the open and closed
arms and the amount of time spent in the open and closed arms were
measured. For an arm entry to be measured, all four paws had to be
within the arm. Mice normally prefer the closed arms of the plus maze. Anxiolytic drugs typically increase the proportion of open arm entries
and the time spent on the open arm (anxiolysis). The elevated plus maze
is able to detect both anxiolytic and anxiogenic agents in mice
(Lister, 1987
).
Low-dose locomotor activation. Sedative/hypnotic drugs commonly cause locomotor activation after low doses. This has been ascribed to an anxiolytic effect, because locomotion may be an expression of increased exploration in the absence of anxiety. The information obtained from elevated plus maze testing (i.e., total number of arm entries) was used as the estimate of locomotor activation.
Seizure protection.
Mice were administered the convulsant
PTZ (5 mg/ml in saline) via timed tail vein infusion into a
lateral vein (0.5 ml/min infusion rate). Latencies to each convulsion
measure were recorded in seconds and subsequently converted to
threshold convulsant dosage (i.e., milligram of drug per
kilogram of body weight). This method allowed for observation and
qualitative analysis of several different endpoints (i.e.,
MC twitch, FF clonus, RB clonus and THE). Drugs that alter seizure
threshold can be tested for pro- or anticonvulsant activity by
pretreating mice and observing the effect on PTZ seizure threshold. A
decreased PTZ seizure threshold indicates proconvulsant activity,
whereas an increased PTZ threshold suggests anticonvulsant activity.
This simple method has been used to demonstrate the anticonvulsant
efficacy of 3
,5
-THP (Finn and Gee, 1994
; Finn et al.,
1995a
,b
).
RIA
The RIA for 3
,5
-THP was adapted from the method of Purdy
et al. (1990)
and is described in detail elsewhere (Finn and
Gee, 1994
). The RIA used a polyclonal antiserum, which was kindly
provided by CoCensys, Inc. (Irvine, CA), and
[3H]3
,5
-THP (54 Ci/mmol; New England Nuclear,
Boston, MA). Counts per minute were normalized and fit to a
least-squares-fit regression equation produced by log-logit
transformation of the standards. The mass of samples was calculated by
interpolation of the standards and correction for recovery. The minimum
detectable limit in the present assay was 25 pg. The intraassay
coefficient of variation averaged 14%, and the interassay coefficient
of variation in seven assays averaged 15%.
Data Analysis
The data are expressed as the mean ± S.E. Analysis of
variance was used to assess strain and dose effects on the dependent variables muscle relaxation (change in baseline forelimb grip strength), ataxia (change in baseline Rotarod performance), locomotor activity (total arm entries on the elevated plus maze), anxiolysis (percent open arm entries on the plus maze), seizure protection (threshold dose for onset to MC twitch, FF clonus, RB clonus and THE)
and plasma 3
,5
-THP concentration. When appropriate, simple main-effects analyses followed by post hoc comparisons were
used to examine significant dose effects within each strain. Because the results of experiment 1 indicated that B6 and D2 mice differed in
sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP, statistical analyses for experiment 2 were conducted on each strain separately.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Experiment 1: anticonvulsant sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP.
To
evaluate whether differences in sensitivity to an endogenous
anticonvulsant steroid (i.e., 3
,5
-THP) contribute to
the genetic differences in ethanol withdrawal severity found in B6 and
D2 mice, it was important to first investigate anticonvulsant sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP in ethanol-naive animals. The results indicated that vehicle-treated D2 mice were more sensitive to PTZ than
B6 animals, as illustrated in figure 1 for all
convulsion measures (compare with vehicle-treated animals in fig. 1).
More importantly, B6 mice were more sensitive than D2 mice to the
anticonvulsant effect of 3
,5
-THP, as measured by the increase in
PTZ seizure threshold for onset to MC twitch (fig. 1A) and FF clonus
(fig. 1B). There were significant main effects of strain
[F(1,54) > 94.3, P < .0001] and dose
[F(2,54) > 28.7, P < .0001], with significant interactions between strain and dose [F(2,54) > 6.5, P < .005]. Post hoc tests indicated that both doses
of 3
,5
-THP significantly increased PTZ seizure threshold in B6
mice, whereas only the 10 mg/kg dose significantly increased seizure
threshold in D2 mice. Analysis of the RB clonus (fig. 1C) and THE (fig.
1D) results indicated that there were significant main effects of
strain [F(1,52) > 9.5, P < .005] and dose
[F(2,52) > 21.7, P < .0001]. The interaction between main effects was a nonsignificant trend for RB clonus [F(2,52) = 2.73, P = .07] and was not significant for
THE [F(2,52) = 1.18], suggesting that the anticonvulsant
effects of 3
,5
-THP against PTZ-induced RB clonus and THE were
similar in B6 and D2 mice.
|
,5
-THP. Analysis of the RIA data (fig. 2) showed
that the dose of 3
,5
-THP [F(2,47) = 165.62, P < .0001], but not the strain [F(1,47) = 1.41],
significantly altered plasma 3
,5
-THP levels. The interaction
between strain and dose was also not significant [F(2,47) = .05], suggesting that injection of 3
,5
-THP produced similar
increases in plasma 3
,5
-THP concentrations in both B6 and D2
mice.
|
Experiment 2: behavioral sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP.
The
results of experiment 1 indicated that B6 mice were more sensitive than
D2 animals to the anticonvulsant effect of 3
,5
-THP and that this
difference in sensitivity was not pharmacokinetic. Subsequent studies
evaluated whether this strain difference in sensitivity to the
anticonvulsant effect of 3
,5
-THP was generalized across several
of the pharmacological effects of 3
,5
-THP.
,5
-THP produced locomotor stimulation and anxiolysis (measured
on the elevated plus maze) (fig. 3), varying amounts of seizure
protection (fig. 4) and muscle relaxation and ataxia (fig. 5). The
differences between the two strains in the doses of 3
,5
-THP
producing pharmacological effects suggested that B6 mice were more
sensitive than D2 mice to the anxiolytic, locomotor stimulant and
anticonvulsant effects of 3
,5
-THP. In contrast, D2 mice appeared
to be more sensitive than B6 mice to the muscle relaxation and ataxia
produced by 3
,5
-THP.
|
|
|
,5
-THP before testing on the elevated plus
maze produced locomotor stimulation, as measured by the total number of
entries, in B6 [F(5,39) = 3.28, P < .02] and D2
[F(5,39) = 2.28, P < .07] mice, although the effect
was marginally significant in D2 animals (fig. 3A). Post hoc
analyses indicated that the 10 mg/kg dose of 3
,5
-THP
significantly increased the total number of entries for B6 animals
vs. vehicle. In addition, the number of entries for B6 mice
injected with 3.2 and 10 mg/kg was significantly greater than for
animals injected with the 1 mg/kg dose. Exogenous administration of
3
,5
-THP also produced anxiolysis, as measured by the percent open
arm entries on the plus maze, in both B6 mice [F(5,36) = 2.55, P < .05] and D2 mice [F(5,39) = 2.80, P < .05] (fig. 3B). Post hoc tests found that there was a
significant increase in the percent open arm entries in B6 mice
administered 3.2 and 10 mg/kg 3
,5
-THP and a nonsignificant trend
for an increase in percent open arm entries in D2 animals injected with
17 and 32 mg/kg 3
,5
-THP vs. the respective
vehicle-treated animals. Thus, the dose-response curve for B6 mice
appeared to be shifted to the left of that for D2 mice
(i.e., greater sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP in B6
vs. D2 mice).
Consistent with the results of experiment 1, B6 mice were more
sensitive than D2 animals to the anticonvulsant effect of 3
,5
-THP against PTZ-induced convulsions (fig. 4). 3
,5
-THP significantly increased the PTZ-induced threshold dose for onset to MC twitch (fig.
4A) and FF clonus (fig. 4B) in both B6 mice [F(5,33) > 4.97, P
.002] and D2 mice [F(5,37) > 3.70, P < .01]. Post hoc tests for the B6 mice found a
dose-dependent increase in PTZ seizure threshold for onset to MC twitch
and FF clonus in the animals injected with doses ranging from 3.2 to 32 mg/kg 3
,5
-THP. In the D2 animals, administration of 32 mg/kg
3
,5
-THP significantly increased the threshold dose for onset to
MC twitch, whereas 17 and 32 mg/kg 3
,5
-THP significantly
increased the threshold dose for FF clonus. Analysis of the RB clonus
(fig. 4C) and THE (fig. 4D) data indicated that 3
,5
-THP produced
similar significant increases in PTZ seizure threshold in B6 mice
[F(5,32 > 8.84, P < .0001] and D2 mice
[F(3,33) > 15.75, P < .0001]. In both strains, the
threshold dose for onset to RB clonus and THE was significantly higher
in animals administered the 17 and 32 mg/kg doses of 3
,5
-THP, compared with the respective vehicle-treated animals as well as with
the animals administered the 1, 3.2 and 10 mg/kg doses.
In contrast to the anticonvulsant and anxiolytic results, D2 animals
appeared to be more sensitive than B6 mice to the muscle relaxant (fig.
5A) and ataxic (fig. 5B) effects of 3
,5
-THP. Administration of
3
,5
-THP produced significant muscle relaxation, measured by the
percent change in base-line grip strength (fig. 5A), in both B6 mice
[F(5,39) = 3.92, P < .01] and D2 mice
[F(5,39) = 36.05, P < .0001]. Both the 17 and 32 mg/kg doses of 3
,5
-THP significantly decreased baseline grip
strength in D2 mice, whereas only the 32 mg/kg dose significantly
decreased grip strength in B6 animals. Injection of 3
,5
-THP also
significantly affected Rotarod performance (fig. 5B) for both B6 mice
[F(5,37) = 2.86, P < .05] and D2 mice
[F(5,39) = 3.27, P < .02]. Whereas the 32 mg/kg dose
significantly decreased Rotarod performance in D2 mice, the 10 mg/kg
dose significantly increased Rotarod performance in B6 mice. The
apparent enhancement of base-line Rotarod performance in B6 mice after
10 mg/kg 3
,5
-THP may be related to the locomotor activation also
found in B6 mice after this dose of 3
,5
-THP (fig. 3A).
Analysis of the plasma samples (fig. 6), which were
taken upon completion of the behavioral testing (i.e., at
approximately 60 min after injection of 3
,5
-THP), indicated that
exogenous administration of 3
,5
-THP produced a dose-dependent
increase in plasma 3
,5
-THP concentrations in both B6 mice
[F(5,30) = 26.36, P < .0001] and D2 mice
[F(5,30) = 14.71, P < .0001]. In B6 mice, plasma
3
,5
-THP levels were significantly higher in the animals injected
with 10, 17 and 32 mg/kg vs. vehicle. The plasma
3
,5
-THP concentration in the 32 mg/kg-treated mice was also
significantly higher than in all other 3
,5
-THP-injected animals,
whereas the plasma 3
,5
-THP level in the 17 mg/kg-treated animals
was significantly higher than in the animals injected with the 1, 3.2 and 10 mg/kg doses. In D2 mice, plasma 3
,5
-THP levels were
significantly higher in the 17 and 32 mg/kg-treated animals, compared
with vehicle-treated animals and animals injected with the 1, 3.2 and
10 mg/kg doses.
|
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The results of the present studies suggest that B6 mice were more
sensitive than D2 animals to the anxiolytic, locomotor stimulant and
anticonvulsant effects of 3
,5
-THP. In contrast, D2 mice appeared
to be more sensitive than B6 mice to the muscle relaxation and ataxia
produced by 3
,5
-THP. Although these results do not indicate that
increased sensitivity to endogenous 3
,5
-THP in B6 mice is the
factor responsible for their decreased seizure susceptibility, relative
to D2 animals, the enhanced sensitivity to the anticonvulsant effect of
exogenous 3
,5
-THP in B6 vs. D2 mice is consistent with
their genetic differences in seizure susceptibility and ethanol
withdrawal severity (i.e., decreased seizure susceptibility
and ethanol withdrawal severity in B6 vs. D2 mice). More
important, the genetic differences in sensitivity to the
pharmacological effects of 3
,5
-THP were not pharmacokinetic, because plasma 3
,5
-THP levels did not differ in B6 and D2 mice after injection of this neuroactive steroid.
The conclusion that B6 mice were more sensitive than D2 mice to the
anxiolytic and locomotor stimulant effects of 3
,5
-THP was based
on the results obtained from testing on the elevated plus maze
(i.e., percent open arm entries and total entries). Recent
work has indicated that additional behavioral measures, collectively
referred to as "risk assessment," may enhance the sensitivity of
the elevated plus maze as an animal model of anxiety (Cole and Rodgers,
1994
). Although these behavioral assessments were not evaluated in the
present study, the 3
,5
-THP-induced anxiolysis in B6 and D2 mice
is consistent with published results, which have used several animal
models of anxiety (Bitran et al., 1991
; Weiland et
al., 1991
, 1995
). Nonetheless, future studies that incorporate
these risk assessment behaviors may yield more information about
differences between genotypes in 3
,5
-THP-induced anxiolysis.
Administration of 3
,5
-THP significantly increased plasma
3
,5
-THP concentrations in both inbred strains. Depending on the experiment, doses of 3
,5
-THP of
5 mg/kg produced a significant increase in plasma 3
,5
-THP levels, compared with the respective vehicle-treated animals. Even though the highest dose of 3
,5
-THP administered (i.e., 32 mg/kg) produced significant ataxia
and plasma concentrations ranging from 450 to 480 ng/ml, these levels are considerably lower than the anesthetic levels recently reported for
mice (Mok et al., 1991
). Brain 3
,5
-THP levels were not
measured in the present study. However, the data reported by Mok
et al. (1991)
indicated that i.v. administration of
3
,5
-THP produced peak brain levels within 1 min of injection.
Because the animals in the present studies were euthanized for
determination of plasma 3
,5
-THP concentrations at approximately
30 or 60 min after injection of 3
,5
-THP, the plasma levels should
reflect brain 3
,5
-THP levels. Therefore, it is unlikely that
differences in brain 3
,5
-THP levels between B6 and D2 mice
administered 3
,5
-THP contributed to the differences in
sensitivity to the pharmacological effects of 3
,5
-THP.
Comparisons between endogenous 3
,5
-THP levels and plasma
3
,5
-THP concentrations after injection suggest that exogenous administration of low doses of 3
,5
-THP may lead to
physiologically relevant concentrations. Doses of 3
,5
-THP ranging
from 3.2 to 32 mg/kg were significantly anticonvulsant in B6 mice, with
doses of 3.2 and 10 mg/kg producing significant anxiolysis in these animals. Although data are limited, endogenous plasma 3
,5
-THP levels of
30 ng/ml or
100 nM have been reported to occur under some
conditions (Paul and Purdy, 1992
). Therefore, the 3.2 mg/kg dose of
3
,5
-THP, which produced a 34 ng/ml plasma level in B6 mice and
was anxiolytic and anticonvulsant in these animals, might be
physiologically relevant. Administration of the 5 or 10 mg/kg doses
produced plasma 3
,5
-THP concentrations that were at least 2- to
3-fold higher than published endogenous levels measured after swim
stress or during pregnancy (Paul and Purdy, 1992
). Because recent work
demonstrated that endogenous 3
,5
-THP levels were higher in brain
than in plasma (Corpechot et al., 1993
), the possibility
exists that the plasma 3
,5
-THP concentrations achieved after
exogenous administration of 5 or 10 mg/kg 3
,5
-THP in the present
studies may more closely reflect values attainable in the brain under
some circumstances.
The strain differences in sensitivity to the anticonvulsant effect of
3
,5
-THP were similar in the two experiments, in which animals
were injected 15 min (experiment 1) vs. 50 min (experiment 2) before infusion of PTZ. Although there was a slight decrease in the
protection provided by 3
,5
-THP in the animals tested at 50 min
after injection, the dose-dependent increase in PTZ threshold was still
evident in B6 mice and lacking in D2 mice. This time-dependent decrease
in sensitivity to the anticonvulsant effect of the same dose of
3
,5
-THP in experiment 2 vs. experiment 1 is
exemplified by the differences between the two experiments in plasma
3
,5
-THP concentrations after the same dose of 3
,5
-THP (e.g., 10 mg/kg). These results also are consistent with
recent work, which determined that protection by 3
,5
-THP against
PTZ-induced convulsions peaked at 15 min after injection of
3
,5
-THP, had decreased to approximately 60% by 60 min after
injection and was no longer apparent at 180 min after injection (Kokate
et al., 1994
). More importantly, there was no difference in
the PTZ thresholds of vehicle-treated animals tested at 15 or 50 min
after injection. This emphasizes that the series of behavioral tests
did not alter basal seizure susceptibility to PTZ.
The strain difference in sensitivity to the anticonvulsant effect of
3
,5
-THP was not generalized across all seizure measures. B6 mice
were more sensitive than D2 mice to the 3
,5
-THP-induced increase
in the threshold dose of PTZ for onset to MC twitch and FF clonus. The
two strains had similar increases in the threshold dose for onset to
PTZ-induced RB clonus and THE after administration of 3
,5
-THP.
These strain differences in anticonvulsant sensitivity to
3
,5
-THP, which vary with the seizure measure, may be related to
the different anatomical systems that are believed to underlie the two
major types of convulsions. Specifically, forebrain substrates (predominantly limbic) appear to be important in mediating MC twitch
and FF clonus, whereas brainstem circuitry (e.g., caudal midbrain and pontine reticular formation) appears to be important for
RB clonus and THE (for review, see Gale, 1988
). Because there are brain
regional variations in the distribution of GABAA receptor subunit mRNAs (Vicini, 1991
; Laurie et al., 1992
; Wisden
et al., 1992
) and in the potency of 3
,5
-THP as a
modulator of the GRC (Gee and Lan, 1991
; Sapp et al., 1992
),
it is possible that the potency of 3
,5
-THP at its site on the GRC
in these two strains may differ within specific brain regions. In other
words, increased sensitivity of GABAA receptors in the
hippocampus, amygdala and other limbic structures to 3
,5
-THP in
B6 vs. D2 mice would be consistent with the increased
sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP-induced anxiolysis and anticonvulsant
effects, as measured by the threshold dose for onset to MC twitch and
FF clonus, in B6 vs. D2 mice. Likewise, the similar increase
in threshold dose for onset to RB clonus and THE in B6 and D2 mice
suggests that the sensitivities of GABAA receptors to
3
,5
-THP in brainstem circuitry are similar in these animals.
It is noteworthy that administration of the 10 mg/kg dose of
3
,5
-THP to B6 mice was anxiolytic and anticonvulsant and
stimulated activity but did not produce muscle relaxation or ataxia.
This result is consistent with recent findings in both genetically heterogeneous and inbred mouse strains (Weiland et al.,
1995
) and suggests that the pharmacological effects of 3
,5
-THP
can be dissociated in some genotypes. However, in the present studies D2 animals were sensitive to the anxiolytic and anticonvulsant effects
of 3
,5
-THP only at doses that also produced muscle relaxation and
ataxia.
Overall, the present results suggest that there are genetic differences
in sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP, which vary, depending on the
pharmacological effect. Coupled with recent results obtained in the
selectively bred Withdrawal Seizure-Prone and -Resistant mice,
indicating that chronic ethanol treatment significantly decreased
endogenous 3
,5
-THP levels only in Withdrawl Seizure-Prone mice
(Finn et al., 1994
), these results are consistent with the hypothesis that genetic differences in neuroactive steroid sensitivity and biosynthesis may contribute to ethanol withdrawal severity. In
addition, the differences in sensitivity to 3
,5
-THP found in B6
and D2 mice can be further evaluated, because these animals are the
progenitor strains from which 26 recombinant inbred strains have been
derived by F2 crosses (i.e., BXD Recombinant Inbred strains). Therefore, future studies can use this genetic animal model
to determine genetic correlations between measures of 3
,5
-THP sensitivity and ethanol-related traits, including withdrawal severity.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank Guy Jones for expert technical assistance. The
3
,5
-THP was synthesized by Robert H. Purdy, Ph.D. The antibody to 3
,5
-THP was a generous gift from CoCensys (Irvine, CA).
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Accepted for publication October 7, 1996.
Received for publication May 22, 1996.
1 This research was supported by grants from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (AA10760 and AA08621) and the Department of Veterans Affairs.
2 Current address: Department of Neuropharmacology, CVN-7, The Scripps Research Institute, 10666 N. Torrey Pines Rd., La Jolla, CA 92037.
Send reprint requests to: Deborah A. Finn, Ph.D., Research Service (151W), Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, 3710 SW U.S. Veterans Hospital Road, Portland, OR 97201.
| |
Abbreviations |
|---|
B6, C57BL/6;
D2, DBA/2;
FF clonus, face and
forelimb clonus;
GABA,
-aminobutyric acid;
GRC,
-aminobutyric
acidA receptor complex;
MC twitch, myoclonic twitch;
PTZ, pentylenetetrazol;
RB clonus, running bouncing clonus;
RIA, radioimmunoassay;
3
, 5
-THDOC,
3
,21-dihydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one;
THE, tonic hindlimb extension;
3
, 5
-THP, 3
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-pregnan-3
-ol-20-one.
Eur. J. Pharmacol.
166: 325-329, 1989[Medline].
-hydroxy-5
[
]-pregnan-20-one: Endogenous metabolites that are active at the GABAA receptor.
Brain Res.
561: 157-161, 1991[Medline].
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one and its precursors in the brain, plasma and steroidogenic glands of male and female rats.
Endocrinology
133: 1003-1009, 1993[Abstract].
-Aminobutyric acidA receptor complexes in rat frontal cortex and spinal cord show differential responses to steroid modulation.
Mol. Pharmacol.
40: 995-999, 1991[Abstract].
-aminobutyric acid-evoked chloride current potentiation.
J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther.
270: 1223-1229, 1994
-pregnan-3
-ol-20-one as an active anesthetic agent.
J. Neurochem.
57: 1296-1301, 1991[Medline].
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one in rat and human plasma.
Steroids
55: 290-296, 1990[Medline].
-aminobutyric acidA receptors in rat brain.
J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther.
262: 801-808, 1992
-OH,5
-pregnan-20-one and 3
-OH,5
-pregnan-20-one in rodents.
Psychopharmacology
118: 65-71, 1995[Medline].
-pregnan-3
-ol-20-one.
Brain Res.
565: 263-268, 1991[Medline].
| ||||||||||