Department of Pharmacology, Faculty of Medicine, University of
Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1H 8 M5
 |
Introduction |
Excitatory amino acids receptors
can be classified into at least three types according to their specific
affinity for selective agonists, namely NMDA, AMPA and kainic acid
(Monaghan et al., 1989
). These receptors are coupled to
cation channels that open in response to agonist stimulation which
causes the depolarization of the target cell. The NMDA receptor channel
complex is endowed with several special features that distinguish it
from AMPA or kainate receptor channels. These features include a
sensitivity to blockade by a physiological concentration of
Mg++, a high permeability to Ca++ and a
requirement of glycine as positive allosteric regulator (Rogawski and
Porter, 1990
). Animal studies indicate that the NMDA receptor is
involved in several physiological phenomena including developmental
plasticity (Tsumoto et al., 1987
; Rauschecker and Hahn,
1987
; Kleinschecker et al., 1987
; Cline et al.,
1987
), learning and memory processes (Collingridge and Bliss, 1987
;
Morris et al., 1986
), sensory transmission (Spierra and
Davis, 1988
; Kemp and Sillito, 1982
; Salt, 1986
) and the control of
respiration (Foutz et al., 1988
) and blood pressure (Kubo
and Kihara, 1988
). Major advances that were recently achieved in our
understanding of the role of excitatory amino acid receptors in the
etiology of neuropathophysiological conditions provide new potential
therapeutic approaches. Overstimulation of these sites induce
excitotoxic effects manifested by various cellular events that include
the excessive entry of Ca++, the activation of lipases and
phospholipases, the production of free radicals and ultimately neuronal
cell death (Olney, 1990
). Thus, excitatory amino acids have been
suggested to participate in the pathophysiology of some neurological
disorders that include cerebral ischemia (Meldrum, 1985
; Rothman and
Olney, 1987
; Herrling, 1989
), hypoglycemia (Weiloch, 1985
), epilepsy
(Croucher et al., 1982
; Meldrum et al., 1989
;
Rogawski and Porter, 1990
), anxiogenesis (Stephens et al.,
1986
), motor-neuron diseases (Spencer et al., 1986
) and
olivopontocerebellar atrophy (Plaitakis, 1984
). The possibility of
providing a rational therapy for these conditions has prompted a search
for specific NMDA antagonists with potential neuroprotective activities
(Watkins and Olverman, 1987
; Watkins et al., 1990
; Rogawski
and Porter, 1990
).
Competitive and noncompetitive NMDA receptor antagonists offer
protection against convulsions and neuronal cell death in different animal models (Collingridge and Lester, 1989
; Rogawski and Porter, 1990
). Despite their high anticonvulsant properties, all the NMDA antagonists have the unfortunate problem of causing neurological side
effects on motor performance and memory function at doses similar to or
close to those that provide significant protection (Morris et
al., 1986
, 1989
; Löscher et al., 1988
;
Tricklebank et al., 1989
). In rats and mice, NMDA
antagonists produce PCP-like behavioral effects (Bernard and Bennett,
1986
; Koek et al., 1987
; Liebman et al., 1987
;
Compton et al., 1987
; Iversen et al., 1988
; Koek
and Colpaert, 1990
). At present, it is unknown whether these or other
side effects will limit the usefulness of NMDA receptor antagonists in
the treatment of different neurological disorders. Therefore, there is
a need to develop NMDA antagonists devoid of motor or toxic side
effects at therapeutic doses. Such compounds may prove useful for the
prevention of brain cell damage mainly in cases of cerebral ischaemia
(Holden, 1993
).
Morphinans are opiate compounds with chemical structures related to
those of levorphanol, dextrorphan and dextromethorphan. These drugs were clinically introduced in the 60s for their analgesic and antitussive properties (Benson et al., 1953
). They do
not produce neurological side effects at therapeutic doses. Renewed interest in these drugs derives from the recent findings regarding the
anticonvulsant and neuroprotective antiischemic effects of dextrorphan
and dextromethorphan in different experimental tests with laboratory animals (Ferkany et al., 1988
; Moreau
et al., 1989
; Steinberg et al., 1989
; Tortella
and Musacchio, 1986
). The anticonvulsant and neuroprotective effects of
these drugs were ascribed to their glutamate-antagonist properties
(Steinberg et al., 1989
). Dextrorphan and
dextromethorphan counteract, in a noncompetitive way,
the excitatory properties of N-methyl-D-aspartate, both
in vitro and in vivo (Church et al.,
1985
; Choi, 1987
; Goldberg et al., 1987
). Recently, we have
demonstrated that the resolved axial (
) form of
S-allylmorphinan (
-sulfallorphan) has no opioid activity
while the equatorial (
) form of S-allylmorphinan
(
-sulfallorphan) has opioid antagonist activity (Lemaire et
al., 1994
). In the present study, the NMDA receptor antagonist
activity and motor effects (locomotion and falling behavior) of
-
and
-sulfallorphans were assessed and compared with those of
prototypic NMDA antagonists.
 |
Materials and Methods |
Drugs.
The axial and equatorial forms of
S-allylmorphinan (
-sulfallorphan and
-sulfallorphan)
were synthesized in the laboratory of Dr. Bernard Belleau, Biochem
Pharma, Laval (Belleau et al., 1985
; 1986
). The various
conformers were separated by high-performance liquid chromatography
(Belleau et al., 1985
). NMDA and kainic acid were purchased
from Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO. AMPA and (+)bicuculline were
products of Research Biochemical Incorporated, Natick, MA. CPP and
MK-801 were obtained from Tocris Neuramin, Essex, England.
[3H]MK-801 (22.3 Ci/mmol) and
[3H](+)pentazocine (35 Ci/mmol) were purchased from New
England Nuclear, Boston, MA. Levorphanol, dextrorphan,
dextromethorphan, levallorphan and dextrallorphan were
products of Hoffman La Roche, Ltd. (Vaudreuil, Quebec).
Animals.
Male Swiss Webster [(SW)fBR] mice (20-25 g;
Canadian Breeding Farm, St-Constant, Quebec) were housed five per cage
in a room with controlled temperature (22 ± 2°C), humidity and
artificial light (6:30 A.M. to 7:00 P.M.). The
animals had free access to food and water and were used after a minimum
of 4 days of acclimation to housing conditions.
Radioligand binding.
The mouse brain membranes were prepared
as described previously (Rogers and Lemaire, 1993
). Mice were
sacrificed by decapitation, and their brains were homogenized with a
glass Teflon homogenizer in 10 volumes (w/v) of ice-cold 5 mM Tris-HCl
buffer (pH 7.4; buffer A). The homogenate was centrifuged at
27,000 × g for 30 min at 4°C. The pellet was
resuspended in buffer A, incubated at 37°C for 30 min and centrifuged
at the same speed. The resulting pellet was resuspended in buffer A
containing 0.3 M KCl and stirred at 4°C for 60 min (Lee et
al., 1982
). The suspension was recentrifuged at 27,000 × g for 30 min at 4°C, and the pellet was washed twice in 10 volumes of buffer A. The final membrane pellet was resuspended in
buffer A at a concentration of 1.2 mg protein/ml and frozen at
80°C. Proteins were measured by the method of Lowry et
al. (1951)
with bovine serum albumin diluted in the same milieu as membrane samples as standard. [3H]MK-801 and
[3H](+)-pentazocine were used to monitor the interaction
of
- and
-sulfallorphan with PCP and sigma receptors,
respectively (Shukla et al., 1992
; Bowen et al.,
1993
). Binding assays were performed in buffer A at room temperature
(22°C) for 30 min with a 2-ml aliquot of membrane preparation (1 mg
protein) in presence of [3H]MK-801 (5 nM) and increasing
concentrations (10
9-10
5 M) of
- or
-sulfallorphan. Incubations were terminated by filtration under
reduced pressure through GF934AH Whatman filters pretreated with 0.05%
polyethylenimine. Filters were washed with 4 × 3 ml aliquots of
ice-cold buffer A, placed in liquid scintillation vials along with 10 ml Ecolume (ICN Biochemical Inc., Mississauga, Ontario, Canada) and
counted in a Beckman scintillation counter. Nonspecific binding of
[3H]MK-801 was determined in the presence of 10 µM
MK-801. Specific binding was defined as the difference between the
radiolabel bound in the presence and absence of MK-801. The
concentration of
- or
-sulfallorphan that produced 50%
inhibition of [3H]MK-801 binding (IC50) was
derived by use of the nonlinear least-square computer fitting program
CDATA (EMF Software, Knoxville, TN). Ki
values were calculated by the method of Cheng and Prusoff (1973)
. The
effect of
- and
-sulfallorphan on the sigma receptor
was also monitored, with the sigma receptor ligand
[3H](+)-pentazocine (5 nM). The binding experiments were
performed as described above, and the nonspecific binding was
determined in the presence of 10 µM haloperidol.
Anticonvulsive activity.
Mice were coinjected i.c.v. with
various doses of
-sulfallorphan (0.2-1.0 nmol, as indicated) or
-sulfallorphan (0.05-0.4 nmol, as indicated) and increasing doses
of the convulsant compounds, NMDA (0.25-2.0 nmol), AMPA (0.25-5
nmol), kainic acid (0.25-0.75 nmol) or bicuculline (1-10 nmol) in a
total volume of 10 µl of saline. Control experiments were conducted
in the absence of the morphinan derivative. The animals were observed
for 30 min for the signs of convulsions and death. The convulsive
response to different convulsants began within 5 min and was
characterized. The following responses were noted during the
observation period: 1) mild myoclonus (moderate jerky movement of one
or two limbs); 2) whole body clonus (dramatic and violent movements
involving all the limbs and the body leading to loss of the righting
reflex); 3) clonic-tonic seizures consisting of the following
successive components: wild running characterized by episodes of
running with explosive jumps, clonus and finally tonus characterized by extreme rigidity of the whole body. Groups of 15 animals were injected
with increasing doses of an analeptic (NMDA, AMPA, kainate or
bicuculline) in the presence or abscence of morphinan derivatives, as
indicated. The animals were scored as showing seizure activity when one
or more of the three responses mentioned above were present, and the
number of animals showing these behavioral signs of convulsions in each
group was recorded. The doses of different convulsants which, alone and
in combination with increasing doses of
- or
-sulfallorphan,
produced convulsions (CD50) and lethality
(LD50) in 50% of animals with 95% confidence limits (95%
CL) and potency ratios with 95% CL were calculated by the method of
Litchfield and Wilcoxon by procedure 47 of the computer program of
Tallarida and Murray (1987)
.
Similarly in other sets of experiments increasing doses of
-sulfallorphan,
-sulfallorphan, dextrorphan,
dextromethorphan, dextrallorphan, MK-801 and CPP were
coadministered with NMDA (1 nmol/mouse i.c.v.), and the number of
animals showing signs of convulsions at different dose levels in each
treatment group was recorded. The doses of the NMDA-antagonists which
produced protection in 50% of animals (ED50) with 95% CL
and potency ratios with 95% CL were calculated by procedure 47 of the
computer program of Tallarida and Murray (1987)
.
Locomotion and falling behavior.
In this set of experiments,
locomotion and falling behavior were assessed according to a
modificatiion of the procedure of Koek and Colpaert (1990)
. Mice were
placed individually in observation cages for a 60-min habituation
period. Thereafter, animals were injected with increasing doses of
-sulfallorphan,
-sulfallorphan, dextromethorphan,
MK-801 or CPP (10 µl/mouse i.c.v.) and observed for 30 min after the
injection. For each mouse, the presence of locomotion (locomotion with
all four legs moving for at least 15 sec) and falling (falling from a
rearing or standing position backward or to the side) was assessed.
Each dose was tested in 10 mice, and the proportion of mice showing a
particular behavior was determined.
The statistical significance of drug-induced changes in the occurrence
of a particular behavior was tested by means of the method of Fray
et al. (1980)
and also described by Koek and Colpaert (1990)
. For each drug and each behavior, the data were arranged in a
contingency table with two columns (the number of mice out of 10 showing the behavior and the number not showing the behavior) and one
row for each drug dose tested (including the corresponding vehicle
control). The statistic 2I, distributed as
2 with
(i
1)(j
1)dF, was
calculated as: 2I = 2
ij[Nij·ln(Nij/Eij)], where Nij is the observed cell frequency,
Eij is the expected cell frequency (row
total·column total/grand total), and i and j
are row and column numbers, respectively. If 2I was statistically significant, possible dose dependency was tested by using the following
method of planned contrasts. A 2 × 2 cell was constructed with
the number of mice showing and not showing a particular behavior after
the vehicle control and after the lowest drug dose, and 2I was again
calculated. If the lowest drug dose and the vehicle control were
significantly different, the next higher drug dose was compared with
the lowest dose with use of the 2I statistic. If the lowest drug dose
did not differ significantly from the vehicle control, the next higher
dose was compared with the combined results obtained with the lowest
drug dose and the vehicle control. This process was repeated until the
highest drug dose was reached. In this manner, adjacent doses could be
grouped in such a way that there were no significant differences
between members of a group, but adjacent groups were significantly
different at the 5% level. Worked examples of the procedure are given
by Fray et al. (1980)
and Iwamoto (1984)
.
 |
Results |
PCP and sigma receptor binding activity of
- and
-sulfallorphans.
- and
-sulfallorphans were monitored for
their ability to displace the binding of specific PCP
([3H]MK-801) and sigma
([3H](+)-pentazocine) receptor ligands to membrane
preparations of mouse brain (fig. 1).
-Sulfallorphan
was slightly more potent in inhibiting the binding of
[3H](+)-pentazocine (Ki,
1.97 ± 0.16 µM; Hill coefficient, 0.85) than that of
[3H]MK-801 (Ki,
2.32 ± 0.04 µM; Hill coefficient, 0.98) (fig. 1A). On the other
hand,
-sulfallorphan was much more potent in competing with the
binding of [3H]MK-801
(Ki, 0.13 ± 0.01 µM; Hill
coefficient, 0.97) than that of [3H](+)-pentazocine
(Ki, 1.61 ± 0.11 µM; Hill
coefficient, 0.61) (fig. 1B). The ratios between the
sigma/PCP Ki values were 0.85 and 12.4 for
- and
-sulfallorphans, respectively. Thus, both drugs showed similar affinities for the sigma site, whereas
-sulfallorphan displayed a significantly higher affinity for the PCP
site than
-sulfallorphan (P
.05).

View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1.
Effect of increasing concentrations of
-sulfallorphan (A) and -sulfallorphan (B) on the binding of
[3H]MK-801 (closed circle) and
[3H](+)-pentazocine (open circle) to mouse brain
membranes.
|
|
Anticonvulsive activity.
NMDA, AMPA, kainic acid and
bicuculline dose-dependently induced rapid and short-lasting
convulsions in mice.
-Sulfallorphan (1.0 nmol i.c.v.) or
-sulfallorphan (0.4 nmol i.c.v.) alone did not produce any
behavioral change. Coadministration of
-sulfallorphan (0.2-1.0
nmol/mouse; table 1) or
-sulfallorphan (0.05-0.4
nmol/mouse; table 2) with NMDA blocked its convulsive
activity with a corresponding increase in the CD50 and a
significant change in the potency ratio. The anticonvulsive activities
of
- and
-sulfallorphans were also dose dependent (fig.
2, A and B). On the other hand,
-sulfallorphan (1 nmol/mouse) and
-sulfallorphan (0.4 nmol/mouse) did not display any
protection against AMPA-, kainic acid- and bicuculline-induced convulsions (tables 1 and 2, respectively). NMDA- and AMPA-induced mortality was either significantly reduced or totally blocked by
-sulfallorphan (1 nmol/mouse; table 1) and
-sulfallorphan (0.05-0.4 nmol/mouse; table 2), respectively.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 1
Effect of -sulfallorphan on NMDA-, AMPA-, kainic acid- and
bicuculline-induced convulsions and mortality in mice
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 2
Effect of -sulfallorphan on NMDA-, AMPA-, kainic acid- and
bicuculline-induced convulsions and mortality in mice
|
|

View larger version (16K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
(A) Probit-log dose regression curves for
convulsions induced by NMDA (i.c.v.) in mice in the absence (closed
circle) or presence of various doses (0.2, closed square; 0.5, closed
triangle; 1.0, closed diamond, nmol/mouse) of -sulfallorphan. (B)
Probit-log dose regression curves for convulsions induced by NMDA
(i.c.v.) in mice in the absence (closed circle) or presence of various doses (0.05, closed square; 0.10, closed triangle; 0.20, upside-down closed triangle; 0.40, closed diamond, nmol/mouse) of
-sulfallorphan.
|
|
The abilities of
- and
-sulfallorphans to antagonize NMDA (1 nmol)-induced convulsions were compared between each other and with
those of other NMDA antagonists (fig. 3; table
3). Among the various compounds tested,
-sulfallorphan was the most potent blocker of NMDA-induced
convulsions, being 32 times as potent as
-sulfallorphan with an
ED50 of 0.015 nmol/mouse as compared with 0.48 nmol/mouse
for
-sulfallorphan (table 3). Interestingly,
-sulfallorphan had
itself a potency that was comparable with that of dextrorphan
(ED50 of 0.48 as compared with 0.55 nmol/mouse for
dextrorphan) and 10 times higher than that of
dextromethorphan (ED50 of 4.87 nmol/mouse).
-Sulfallorphan was 166 times as potent as its structurally related
compound, dextrallorphan (ED50 of 2.68 nmol/mouse).
Finally, the noncompetitive NMDA antagonist, MK-801, was 2.6 times less
potent than
-sulfallorphan, and the competitive NMDA antagonist,
CPP, displayed a comparable activity (potency ratios of 0.38 and 1.15, respectively). However, the marked locomotor effects of these two
latter compounds impaired the measurement of their anticonvulsive
activity at supramaximal doses (fig. 3).

View larger version (17K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
Log-dose protection curves of -sulfallorphan
(closed circle), -sulfallorphan (open circle), MK-801 (closed
square) and CPP (closed triangle) against convulsions induced by NMDA
(1 nmol i.c.v.) in mice.
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 3
Comparison of the anticonvulsant activity of -sulfallorphan,
-sulfallorphan and various NMDA antagonists against NMDA (1 nmol/mouse)-induced convulsions in mice
|
|
Locomotion and falling behavior.
-Sulfallorphan did
not produce locomotion and falling at doses ranging between 1.25 and 20 nmol (i.c.v.; fig. 4).
-Sulfallorphan produced
locomotion in 20 to 100% of tested mice at doses (
1.25 nmol/mouse)
exceeding its anticonvulsive ED50 value (0.015 nmol/mouse) by factors of 83 or more (fig. 5; table
4). These high doses of
-sulfallorphan did not
produce significant falling (0-10% mice at the tested dose range).
Other NMDA antagonists produced both locomotion and falling behavior at
protective doses. MK-801 (0.125-2.0 nmol i.c.v.) produced significant
increases in locomotion and falling behavior in 30 to 100% and 0 to
50% of mice, respectively (fig. 6). The minimum dose of
MK-801 producing significant falling behavior (1.5 nmol i.c.v.) was
higher than that (0.25 nmol i.c.v.) producing significant locomotion
(table 4). A comparison between the ratios of the lowest effective dose
showing locomotion and the dose showing protection against NMDA-induced
convulsion in 50% of animals (ED50) reveals values of 0.2, 6.4 and 1.9 for dextromethorphan, MK-801 and CPP,
respectively, as compared with 83 for
-sulfallorphan (table 4).

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Locomotion (A) and falling behavior (B) produced by
i.c.v. administration of the indicated doses of -sulfallorphan.
These PCP-like grossly observable behavioral effects were measured as described under "Materials and Methods."
|
|

View larger version (16K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5.
Locomotion (A) and falling behavior (B) produced by
i.c.v. administration of the indicated doses of -sulfallorphan.
These PCP-like grossly observable behavioral effects were measured as described under "Materials and Methods."
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 4
PCP-like behavioral effects (locomotion and falling) of
-sulfallorphan, -sulfallorphan and various NMDA antagonists
|
|

View larger version (13K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6.
Locomotion and falling behavior produced by i.c.v.
administration of the indicated doses of MK-801. These PCP-like grossly observable behavioral effects were measured as described under "Materials and Methods."
|
|
 |
Discussion |
S-Allylmorphinans are morphinan derivatives that
incorporate a cationic sulfuration instead of the nitrogen atom in
position 17 of levallorphan. In these S-morphinan
derivatives, the position of the allyl group is fixed in either
equatorial (
) (e.g.,
S-allyl-equatorial-morphinan:
-sulfallorphan) or axial
(
) (e.g., S-allyl-axial-morphinan:
-sulfallorphan) conformations; whereas the allyl substitution on the
nitrogen atom at position 17 in levallorphan rotates freely either in
the axial or equatorial positions not allowing the stable formation and
separation of axial and equatorial conformers.
Morphinans are known to be stereoselective for their opioid and
nonopioid activity (Collingridge and Lester, 1989
; Murray and Leid,
1984
; Mendelsohn et al., 1984
). At mu opioid
receptors, levorphanol, a levorotatory isomer of
3-hydroxy-N-methylmorphinan, is approximately 4,000 times more potent
than dextrorphan, a dextrorotatory isomer of the same molecule. On the
other hand, dextrorphan affinity for [3H]PCP binding
sites is 2.3 times greater than that of levorphanol (Murray and Leid,
1984
). Previous studies indicated that the axial and equatorial
orientation of the allyl group in sulfallorphan is also important for
its opioid activity. In the mu receptor binding assay,
-sulfallorphan was 60 times as potent as
-sulfallorphan (Lemaire
et al., 1994
). The equatorial conformation of the allyl group in sulfallorphan conferred a strong opioid antagonist activity to
the molecule, but the axial conformer was only a weak opioid antagonist
(Lemaire et al., 1994
).
In the present study, we demonstrated that both
- and
-sulfallorphans inhibit the binding of the PCP receptor ligand,
[3H]MK-801, but
-sulfallorphan was 24 times as potent
as
-sulfallorphan. The order of potency of the sulfallorphans on the
PCP site paralleled the potency in the in vivo
anticonvulsive assay (figs. 1 and 3). Noncompetitive antagonists of
NMDA receptors, such as PCP and MK-801, are known to possess
anticonvulsant properties (Chapman and Meldrum, 1989
; Leander et
al., 1988
; Clineschmidt et al., 1982
). The
dextrarotatory opioids, dextrorphan, and its 3-methyl ether derivative,
dextromethorphan, also exhibit anticonvulsant activity
in several in vivo seizure models including NMDA-induced convulsions (Ferkany et al., 1988
; Leander et
al., 1988
; Tortella et al., 1988
; Chapman and Meldrum,
1989
; Roth et al., 1992
; Church et al., 1985
).
Our study indicates that axial and equatorial orientations of the allyl
group in sulfallorphans are important for their NMDA antagonist
activity.
-Sulfallorphan was 31 times more potent than
-sulfallorphan against NMDA (1 nmol)-induced convulsions. Moreover,
-sulfallorphan at all tested doses completely protected against
NMDA-, AMPA- and bicuculline-induced mortality, whereas
-sulfallorphan produced a marked but not total protection against mortality induced by NMDA. It seems unlikely that effects at
sigma receptors make a substantial contribution to the
anticonvulsant and neuroprotective activities of sulfallorphans. The
relative potency of sulfallorphans as anticonvulsants did not
correspond to their potency in inhibiting the binding of the
sigma receptor ligand, [3H](+)pentazocine, to
mouse brain membranes. Neither did the potency of other
PCP/sigma ligands such as SKF 10,047, cyclazocine,
pentazocine and dextromethorphan as anticonvulsants
correlate with their affinity for the sigma binding sites
(Aram et al., 1989
; Sircar et al., 1986
; Largent
et al., 1986
). Pentazocine was weaker than cyclazocine in
inhibiting the epileptiform activity of NMDA-evoked depolarization and
the binding of PCP ligands, but the reverse was observed for their
ability to inhibit the binding of sigma ligands (Aram
et al., 1989
). On the other hand, sigma receptor
ligands were shown to modulate NMDA receptor stimulation (Monnet
et al., 1992
; 1990
; Pontecorvo et al., 1991
).
Sigma selective compounds such as ifenprodil (Contreras
et al., 1990
), BMY 14802 and haloperidol produced some protection and greatly increased the anticonvulsant potency of MK-801
against NMDA-induced convulsions in mice (Pontecorvo et al.,
1991
). Thus, the ability of morphinan derivatives to interfere with the
sigma site may partly explain their protection against NMDA-induced convulsions. Interestingly, the lack of motor effect of
-sulfallorphan (fig. 4) and other morphinan derivatives (Tortella et al., 1994
) corresponds to increased binding selectivity
of these compounds for the sigma receptor as compared with
the PCP receptor.
The mu opioid receptor is not likely to be involved in the
protective activity of sulfallorphans, because naloxone (a
mu opioid antagonist) showed no protection against
NMDA-induced convulsions in mice (Shukla and Lemaire, 1993
). On the
other hand, the mu antagonist activity of sulfallorphans
(mainly
-sulfallorphan) may contribute in attenuating or annulling
motor side effects of the morphinan derivatives (Lemaire et
al., 1994
).
Increasing doses of MK-801 and CPP produced biphasic effects against
NMDA-induced convulsions (e.g., a dose-dependent protection at lower doses and a decrease in the protecting activity at
supramaximal doses; fig. 3). Biphasic dose response curves were also
obtained with MK-801 and NPC-12626 in mice in the experiments related
to protection against hypoxic stress (Pontecorvo et al.,
1991
). In contrast,
- and
-sulfallorphans showed monophasic
protection curves and remained fully protective at supramaximal doses
(fig. 3), which suggested that they may be less toxic than the
prototypic NMDA antagonists MK-801 and CPP.
Noncompetitive NMDA antagonists such as PCP and MK-801, and competitive
antagonists such as AP7, AP5, CPP and CGS19755, produce PCP-like side
effects in rodents. These include stereotypy characterized by increased
locomotion, circling, head weaving and falling behavior. There is a
good correlation between the relative potencies of these compounds in
antagonizing NMDA-induced convulsions and producing PCP-like locomotion
(Koek et al., 1988
; Tricklebank et al., 1989
; Koek and Colpaert, 1990
). In contrast to competitive NMDA antagonists, PCP-like drugs generally antagonize convulsant or lethal effects of
NMDA only at doses higher than those associated with motor disturbances
or PCP-like stereotypy (Willetts et al., 1990
). Competitive antagonists penetrate the brain poorly and it has been suggested that
this may limit their PCP-like effects (Tricklebank et al., 1989
; Koek and Colpaert, 1990
; Koek et al., 1988
). In our
study, i.c.v. administration of competitive (CPP) and noncompetitive (MK-801, dextromethorphan) NMDA antagonists showed
overlaps between the doses producing an increase in locomotor activity
and those producing protection against NMDA-induced convulsions (table
4). Such overlaps were not observed with the two thiamorphinan
derivatives,
- and
-sulfallorphans.
There are some theoretical advantages of noncompetitive over
competitive NMDA antagonists. The blockade of NMDA receptor channel by
noncompetitive antagonists is voltage and use dependent (Davies et al., 1988
; McDonald and Nowak, 1990
). Use dependency
should enhance the efficacy to toxicity ratio of noncompetitive NMDA antagonists compared with that of the competitive antagonists, because
the block would be potentiated during strong stimulation of NMDA
receptors, a condition that corresponds to excitotoxicity and
disease-related nerve degeneration. Another theoretical advantage of
noncompetitive NMDA blockers is the fact that their inhibitory effect
cannot be overcome by high synaptic levels of endogenous transmitters
(Rogawski and Porter, 1990
). It is possible to design more specific
noncompetitive NMDA antagonists because many of the toxic side effects
of PCP, which are not shared by competitive NMDA antagonists, are
probably unrelated to their interaction with the NMDA receptor
(Rogawski et al., 1989
, 1990
). In our study,
-sulfallorphan enhanced locomotor activity at doses 83 times higher
than the ED50 dose for protection against NMDA-induced convulsions, whereas
-sulfallorphan did not produce any measurable motor activity at the tested dose range (up to 20 nmol/mouse i.c.v.). The lack of motor effect of this latter compound may depend on its
poorer ability to bind to the PCP site and/or to its greater affinity
for the sigma or mu sites.
Therefore, we may conclude that: 1) axial (
) and equatorial (
)
S-allylmorphinans are potent NMDA receptor blockers; 2)
-sulfallorphan is more potent than
-sulfallorphan in blocking
NMDA-induced convulsions, but it also displays some PCP-like side
effects; 3)
-sulfallorphan possesses the same potency as dextrorphan
in inhibiting NMDA-induced convulsions, and its lack of PCP-like side
effects suggests that it may be used as a good working model to design
effective neuroprotective agents devoid of motor side effects.
We thank Dr. Gervais Dionne, Dr. John Di Maio and Dr. Dilip M. Dixit of Biochem Therapeutic for their strong support and helpful suggestions.
Accepted for publication September 13, 1996.
Received for publication June 19, 1996.